Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Talk Instruments (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/)
-   -   Self Taught?? (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/40554-self-taught.html)

lieasleep 06-20-2009 02:01 AM

lol i said that. and yeah it helps with that stuff but its not nessecary. learn your chords, start learning songs, and off you go. also learning ear training or how to read music is much more of a bitch to teach yourself than just learning chords and following tabs. plu learning sheet music is only REALLY helpful if you plan on picking up classical guitar at some point.

Antonio 06-20-2009 02:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lieasleep (Post 686533)
lol i said that. and yeah it helps with that stuff but its not nessecary. learn your chords, start learning songs, and off you go. also learning ear training or how to read music is much more of a bitch to teach yourself than just learning chords and following tabs. plu learning sheet music is only REALLY helpful if you plan on picking up classical guitar at some point.

i know what you mean with sheet music, i wouldn't be in a rush to learn it myself. so you can disregard that point.

but tbh, if you really want to make your own music/be able to really jam and play with people and not just play other people's songs, music theory is something that can help you alot. even people who just play chords use it when they want to know where to go next when they're making a song.

trust me, i've played with people who knew that kind of stuff as well as people who only knew how to play other people's songs, and the latter is alot more of a bitch to deal with. it's best, in my experience at least, to learn some theory, so that you could be on the same page with other musicians. not saying you have to know every piece of it, at least know the basic stuff.

and yeah, it's hard to really train your ear, but learning guitar is hard too. you can look up ear training things online that can help you in identifying different notes. it might be hard to learn, but it'll help you out in the longrun.

but hell, that doesn't mean you're necessarily not gonna go anywhere sans theory, there have been plenty of artists who made great music without it, really more from creativity/vision. so imo, i say it's best if you try to do both, try being creative as well as try to learn the fundamentals of music.

lieasleep 06-20-2009 07:59 PM

dude trust me, i know alla that. i play with people A LOT and the fact that i took lesson and got trained in music theory is inifinitely useful, i'm just speaking to those people that feel like picking up a guitar and feel like just playing some tunes y'know?

Antonio 06-20-2009 08:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lieasleep (Post 686996)
dude trust me, i know alla that. i play with people A LOT and the fact that i took lesson and got trained in music theory is inifinitely useful, i'm just speaking to those people that feel like picking up a guitar and feel like just playing some tunes y'know?

ok, i was saying that too, if you just want to play some tunes and stuff, that's fine. i was also saying if you want to do more to learn all the fundamental ****. but yeah, i know what you mean.

JKSmith 06-20-2009 08:46 PM

I'm self taught, I just look up the tabs, play, repeat. You'll eventually get the hang of it.

mr dave 06-20-2009 09:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lieasleep (Post 686533)
plu learning sheet music is only REALLY helpful if you plan on picking up classical guitar at some point.

or if you want to learn to play just about any other instrument out there besides a bass guitar.

personally i don't see the need to 'learn theory' aside from barre chords on a guitar. which is really just a way of learning how to move chord shapes up and down the neck.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Antonio
i've played with people who knew that kind of stuff as well as people who only knew how to play other people's songs, and the latter is alot more of a bitch to deal with. it's best, in my experience at least, to learn some theory, so that you could be on the same page with other musicians.

is this really because they didn't know theory? how much experience did they have playing with other people before jamming with you? if all you've ever done is learn to play other people's songs odds are you've never jammed with much more than this month's guitar world magazine and your stereo (not that i spent the first 5 years of playing guitar doing exactly this hahaha)

it's far less about what you know and way more about how you use it.

Antonio 06-20-2009 10:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 687066)
is this really because they didn't know theory? how much experience did they have playing with other people before jamming with you? if all you've ever done is learn to play other people's songs odds are you've never jammed with much more than this month's guitar world magazine and your stereo (not that i spent the first 5 years of playing guitar doing exactly this hahaha)

it's far less about what you know and way more about how you use it.

.....well, i really wanted to get to my calc homework, but i guess now i'll have to forget about it and drop the class to argue with you!




nah j/k, haha :p:




anyway........

while i do admit that some of the people i've played with haven't had much experience, what do you expect in your high school years? for me, it's rare to find experienced musicians at that age level

even so, most times i jammed i've tried aiming it towards more than just playing along to songs and actually playing with other musicians and sharing musical ideas. tbh, i hardly ever learn songs, unless it's something i really like or if someone asks me to.


but definately, it's how you do it moreso than what you know. the thing is, some people i've played with in the past didn't really try to grasp the concept of either; they were just concerned about doing covers without even wanting to learn the methods behind it or wanting to actually make music of their own. i'm in a band right now, and while pop punk may not be the most free flowing genre, my bandmates and i will still have spontaneous jam sessions, where we just play what comes to mind and not just what's on our setlist.


oh and btw, i've never owned any guitar magazines.

mr dave 06-20-2009 11:03 PM

no worries dude. at this point we're venturing off into personal philosophies on playing music though.

as far as teaching yourself to play the guitar, tabs are where it's at. period.

everything else at that point in the game is superfluous.

you just happen to be well ahead of the curve in relation to your peers. don't swear it, they'll either have lighting bolt moments later on in life or stick to being bedroom shredders. there's nothing wrong with being in a cover band either, successfully imitating professional level entertainers DOES require a certain kind of skill, especially if you cover a wide range of material and styles. not everyone wants to be the next big thing, some people just like playing along and leave the creativity to other people.



oh yeah, my stack of guitar magazines went taller than my knee (i'm 6'3" at that) :p:

Kamikazi Kat 06-22-2009 07:26 PM

I self-taught myself the basics of the drums, took lessons for awhile and then stopped. I moved into a lot of the more advanced stuff on my own. I'd say I learned most of what I learned on my own, although the lessons helped me get a strong foundation on the basics so it was easy to go from their on my own and learn whatever I wanted.

Kamikazi Kat 06-22-2009 07:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neapolitan (Post 660086)
I'm self taught, but I believe there are many advantages of having a teacher.
One thing about guitar is that you can never stop learning. Even if you feel confident that you're a pretty good guitar player, there is something out there to learn, a new riff, a new song, a new genre etc. Having teacher is more like having a mentor or guide. They can show you things that you are not aware of, but they can only pass on hints and tricks, and the right way of doing things, they can not pass on talent. In the end all musicians are self-taught by the fact it is up to them to practice, practice, practice.

I highly agree with this as well. I've had a few moments where somebody might hear me play and they come up to me and say that I'm good and then ask if I take lessons. When I tell them I've taken lessons, they suddenly feel less impressed, like I wouldn't be able to get where I am now without a teacher. Lessons help, but its really up to the musician whether he/she wants to be great or not.

Schredds 06-22-2009 07:38 PM

I am self taught; drums and guitar, I havent played the guitar in years though, I want to start playing again though but this time I want to take lesons.

Astronomer 06-22-2009 07:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Schredds (Post 688314)
I am self taught; drums and guitar, I havent played the guitar in years though, I want to start playing again though but this time I want to take lesons.

I took a few guitar lessons when I was younger and found them useless. Guitar is something you can easily teach yourself, methinks.

Schredds 06-22-2009 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shiseido red (Post 688323)
I took a few guitar lessons when I was younger and found them useless. Guitar is something you can easily teach yourself, methinks.

Ya I played for 4 years and I didnt have a problem learning or writing my own music and never took lessons, by buddy I played in a band with in high school took lesson sand he was learning how to play all kind of different style and he was rapidly getting better with each lesson, maybe it depends on the person, who knows, we'll see.

mr dave 06-22-2009 08:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Schredds (Post 688329)
maybe it depends on the person.

i think this is the biggest factor.

the whole lessons vs. self taught thing seems to boil down to a difference between wanting to develop an ability to play the instrument and understanding the fundamentals of the instrument and its relation to the greater whole of music. you 'can' teach yourself both but one aspect is usually a bit more complicated than the other.

JKSmith 06-22-2009 08:12 PM

I'll bark, if you give me a cookie.

Astronomer 06-22-2009 08:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 688343)
i think this is the biggest factor.

the whole lessons vs. self taught thing seems to boil down to a difference between wanting to develop an ability to play the instrument and understanding the fundamentals of the instrument and its relation to the greater whole of music. you 'can' teach yourself both but one aspect is usually a bit more complicated than the other.

This is true. It also depends on what background history you have with music. When I was little my mother chauffeured me off to classical piano lessons for at least 5 years. Subsequently, I was able to self teach myself guitar and bass etc because I had that theoretical (and practical) musical grounding.

JKSmith 06-22-2009 08:40 PM

I'll do whatever you want for a cookie!

mr dave 06-23-2009 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shiseido red (Post 688363)
This is true. It also depends on what background history you have with music. When I was little my mother chauffeured me off to classical piano lessons for at least 5 years. Subsequently, I was able to self teach myself guitar and bass etc because I had that theoretical (and practical) musical grounding.

i never had formal training, but everyone i know who was forced to piano lessons by their moms (none of them liked it or wanted to go haha) when they were kids benefited from that knowledge later in life and seemed more apt to successfully pick up new instruments and styles.

Astronomer 06-23-2009 02:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 688680)
i never had formal training, but everyone i know who was forced to piano lessons by their moms (none of them liked it or wanted to go haha) when they were kids benefited from that knowledge later in life and seemed more apt to successfully pick up new instruments and styles.

Haha exactly. I hated piano lessons and I hated 'practicing' each week. But now, I'm eternally grateful because my musical knowledge comes in handy.

Luby 06-23-2009 06:14 PM

no one is self-taught nowadays. Self-taught = transcribing songs by ear and/or watching musicians play live, etc. If you learned how to play from online lessons, you're not exactly self-taught, because it's the person(s) in the videos who gave you all the tips, techniques, theory, etc. However, regardless of how much someone teaches you, it's up to you and your practice to make yourself a good musician. I don't think you need official lessons to become good, lots of great guitarists never had a lesson.

Luby 06-23-2009 06:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 687108)
no worries dude. at this point we're venturing off into personal philosophies on playing music though.

as far as teaching yourself to play the guitar, tabs are where it's at. period.

everything else at that point in the game is superfluous.

you just happen to be well ahead of the curve in relation to your peers. don't swear it, they'll either have lighting bolt moments later on in life or stick to being bedroom shredders. there's nothing wrong with being in a cover band either, successfully imitating professional level entertainers DOES require a certain kind of skill, especially if you cover a wide range of material and styles. not everyone wants to be the next big thing, some people just like playing along and leave the creativity to other people.



oh yeah, my stack of guitar magazines went taller than my knee (i'm 6'3" at that) :p:


I will have to disagree with you, strongly at that.

Tabs:

1. Spoil you.

2. Usually give you the wrong information unless you've got an official tab book for a given record.

The best way to go, for both amateur/self-taught musicians AND professional musicians is transcribing (by ear that is). It trains you on so many levels. Together with transcribing you'll need some theory to help you figure out stuff quickly. Knowing the major and minor-pentatonic scales, knowing that most songs nowadays are played in the keys of A, E, Eb and D, and knowing the basic major/minor chord shapes is enough for you to be able to transcribe most modern songs and understand how most songs work in general.

PS. Official tabs are a good way to check how close your transcribing is to the original material, so yes, in that way they are very helpful.

mr dave 06-23-2009 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Luby (Post 689126)
I will have to disagree with you, strongly at that.

Tabs:

1. Spoil you.

2. Usually give you the wrong information unless you've got an official tab book for a given record.

The best way to go, for both amateur/self-taught musicians AND professional musicians is transcribing (by ear that is). It trains you on so many levels. Together with transcribing you'll need some theory to help you figure out stuff quickly. Knowing the major and minor-pentatonic scales, knowing that most songs nowadays are played in the keys of A, E, Eb and D, and knowing the basic major/minor chord shapes is enough for you to be able to transcribe most modern songs and understand how most songs work in general.

PS. Official tabs are a good way to check how close your transcribing is to the original material, so yes, in that way they are very helpful.

i have to assume you've never read a guitar magazine.

1 - tabs 'spoil' a musician about as much as a teacher who just shows them how to play a song without explaining the theory behind it.

2 - see my first comment. you really think guitar world would be asking for the better part of $10 per issue so it could publish tabs it lifted off ultimate-guitar.com? you think it would still publish a monthly print magazine if it ran incorrect tabs?

how do you propose for someone who has no formal training to transcribe by ear? how do you learn scales and chord shapes without taking a lesson or learning them from a magazine / online article first? how are tabs (the magazine version) not a worthwhile method of learning these basic elements?

like i've said a few times already in this thread. not everyone wants to understand the fundamentals of the instrument, some people just want to play along and tabs are more than effective at getting you started to that point. if you want more than that, then yeah you'll obviously need to start learning some theory, how one chooses to do that is up to the individual. even if you chose to ignore the theory that does NOT mean you have not taught yourself how to play the instrument.


i think you're definition of self-taught runs counter to how most people on here consider it. self-taught = learning to play without a teacher. the idea that being self-taught means you transcribed songs by ear is just weird.

Luby 06-23-2009 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 689153)
i have to assume you've never read a guitar magazine.

1 - tabs 'spoil' a musician about as much as a teacher who just shows them how to play a song without explaining the theory behind it.

2 - see my first comment. you really think guitar world would be asking for the better part of $10 per issue so it could publish tabs it lifted off ultimate-guitar.com? you think it would still publish a monthly print magazine if it ran incorrect tabs?

how do you propose for someone who has no formal training to transcribe by ear? how do you learn scales and chord shapes without taking a lesson or learning them from a magazine / online article first? how are tabs (the magazine version) not a worthwhile method of learning these basic elements?

like i've said a few times already in this thread. not everyone wants to understand the fundamentals of the instrument, some people just want to play along and tabs are more than effective at getting you started to that point. if you want more than that, then yeah you'll obviously need to start learning some theory, how one chooses to do that is up to the individual. even if you chose to ignore the theory that does NOT mean you have not taught yourself how to play the instrument.


i think you're definition of self-taught runs counter to how most people on here consider it. self-taught = learning to play without a teacher. the idea that being self-taught means you transcribed songs by ear is just weird.

first of all, i don't remember saying that you need a teacher, i said you need your ears. second, i don't care about the specifics of where you get your tabs. I already told you, I'm cool with someone using legit tabs, as long as they're not the first thing you grab. Even if you want to play music just for fun and nothing else, transcribing will help you get the song right much better than a tab will (tabs don't include timing/meter, they don't tell you how loud/quiet to play a note, etc. and those things are essential to playing a song properly). How is my definition counter to what most people consider here? I said exactly what you said, which is that self-taught = no teacher. When did I ever say you need a teacher? Transcribing is among the most essential elements of being a self-taught musician. Every successful/good self-taught musician transcribes music, a lot. Every good musician in general does so. Read up on transcribing, understand what it is and how important it is.


Yo do not need any training whatsoever to transcribe by ear. Like I said, a basic knowledge of theory helps, but if that is not necessary. You train yourself to transcribe.

Son of JayJamJah 06-23-2009 07:13 PM

I see what Luby is saying about Tabs spoiling you.

Obviously I grew up in a time when I couldn't go to ultimate-guitar and learn to play anything instantly, so I'd sit by the record player and listen over and over again tryig to find the right riff or progression, it certainly made me a better player.

That said, I'll take today's way anytime,so much quicker and more instantly gratifying

mr dave 06-23-2009 07:19 PM

i'm only going to ask this one more time - how is someone supposed to transcribe music without knowing how to play the instrument in the first place?

if you've taken lessons and had a teacher show you the basic chord shapes and scales then you're not self-taught. if you picked up a book / magazine / webpage and figured out those chord shapes and scales on your own then you ARE self-taught. of course someone else has to write those lessons, but that doesn't mean you aren't the one who taught yourself the knowledge within those lessons. otherwise i was taught how to play guitar by billy corgan, john petrucci, kirk hammet, and dimebag darrell...

...and there's no timing/meter or dynamics in tabs? again. you've obviously never read a guitar magazine.

Luby 06-23-2009 07:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JayJamJah (Post 689170)
I see what Luby is saying about Tabs spoiling you.

Obviously I grew up in a time when I couldn't go to ultimate-guitar and learn to play anything instantly, so I'd sit by the record player and listen over and over again tryig to find the right riff or progression, it certainly made me a better player.

That said, I'll take today's way anytime,so much quicker and more instantly gratifying


Yes, it is instantly gratifying, but it is not quicker in the long run. The way I study songs nowadays is transcribing by ear first, then checking with tabs. I can figure out the basic progression to most songs in no time, and I'm sure that would be helpful for anyone, even those who just play for fun and nothing else.

mr dave 06-23-2009 07:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JayJamJah (Post 689170)
I see what Luby is saying about Tabs spoiling you.

that's like blaming mcdonald's for being a fatso.

it's up to the individual to determine what sort of knowledge they glean from the resources they have available.

Astronomer 06-23-2009 07:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Luby (Post 689116)
no one is self-taught nowadays. Self-taught = transcribing songs by ear and/or watching musicians play live, etc. If you learned how to play from online lessons, you're not exactly self-taught, because it's the person(s) in the videos who gave you all the tips, techniques, theory, etc. However, regardless of how much someone teaches you, it's up to you and your practice to make yourself a good musician. I don't think you need official lessons to become good, lots of great guitarists never had a lesson.

But this is how I define self-taught. I teach myself songs by ear. Isn't that exactly what you're saying?

Son of JayJamJah 06-23-2009 07:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 689177)
that's like blaming mcdonald's for being a fatso.

it's up to the individual to determine what sort of knowledge they glean from the resources they have available.

Actually yes it is exactly like that.

Good Point, I wasn't blaming so much though, just relating.

Luby 06-23-2009 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 689175)
i'm only going to ask this one more time - how is someone supposed to transcribe music without knowing how to play the instrument in the first place?

if you've taken lessons and had a teacher show you the basic chord shapes and scales then you're not self-taught. if you picked up a book / magazine / webpage and figured out those chord shapes and scales on your own then you ARE self-taught. of course someone else has to write those lessons, but that doesn't mean you aren't the one who taught yourself the knowledge within those lessons. otherwise i was taught how to play guitar by billy corgan, john petrucci, kirk hammet, and dimebag darrell...

...and there's no timing/meter or dynamics in tabs? again. you've obviously never read a guitar magazine.

you transcribe music by grabbing the guitar and playing the note that you hear. you pick one set of notes, you play them. then you pick another set of notes, you play them over the previous set, and you get harmony. Yes, when you read a magazine, you are self-taught. When you watch a video of a guy telling you how to play, you're not exactly self-taught, because that's pretty close to a real face-to-face teacher/student experience (although, there is no feedback). Yes, there is no timing/meter in tabs. Official/legit tabs usually come together with sheet music. That's where you get your timing/meter.

Luby 06-23-2009 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shiseido red (Post 689182)
But this is how I define self-taught. I teach myself songs by ear. Isn't that exactly what you're saying?

yes that's what i'm saying. but according to the panda dude, you can't possibly play unless some one has taught you theory, etc. or am i getting it wrong? i think we're mostly misunderstanding each other, no bad feelings.

Astronomer 06-23-2009 07:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Luby (Post 689198)
yes that's what i'm saying. but according to the panda dude, you can't possibly play unless some one has taught you theory, etc. or am i getting it wrong? i think we're mostly misunderstanding each other, no bad feelings.

Oh okay, yeah I agree with you. You can play without knowing theory. Heaps of musicians learn purely by ear. Having that background knowledge of theory can be a huge help, but there are plenty of great musicians I know who have gone without it.

mr dave 06-23-2009 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Luby (Post 689198)
yes that's what i'm saying. but according to the panda dude, you can't possibly play unless some one has taught you theory, etc. or am i getting it wrong? i think we're mostly misunderstanding each other, no bad feelings.

no, what i'm saying is you can't start transcribing without knowing how to play first. that, and you 'can' learn the modicum of theory necessary to teach yourself to transcribe music through tablature.

no bad feelings indeed, sorry if we got off on the wrong foot :yeah:

Luby 06-23-2009 08:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 689223)
no, what i'm saying is you can't start transcribing without knowing how to play first. that, and you 'can' learn the modicum of theory necessary to teach yourself to transcribe music through tablature.

no bad feelings indeed, sorry if we got off on the wrong foot :yeah:

i guess there are different ways to see things, and that's how it should be anyways. nice tracks on myspace, btw.

bloodsugar08 06-25-2009 12:36 AM

Self Taught??
 
I just wish I didn't have to pay him for stuff like that, but he's great at helping me with my theory.

Regards

William

Ricochet~kun 06-28-2009 11:34 AM

im self taught... mostly, i more or less picked up guitar and firgured it out for myself

Chaos 06-28-2009 11:40 AM

I am somewhat self taught on the drums.

I would love to have a teacher though.

Ricochet~kun 06-28-2009 12:11 PM

well when your self taught then generally your style is totally unique, and when you have a teacher you generally get some musical traits of the teacher, so i prefer to be self taught, to be unique

Xavier 06-28-2009 04:22 PM

I'm a semi experienced guitarist, been playing for about nine years, and took lessons for four.
if you can't afford to take lessons, or lessons aren't readily available, Just teach yourself chord and scale structure. Not to mention theory!
once you start to get those basics down you can pretty much pick up anything.

Ricochet~kun 06-28-2009 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xavier (Post 693089)
I'm a semi experienced guitarist, been playing for about nine years, and took lessons for four.
if you can't afford to take lessons, or lessons aren't readily available, Just teach yourself chord and scale structure. Not to mention theory!
once you start to get those basics down you can pretty much pick up anything.

really? ive only been playing for two or so years, but for the first year and a half all i did all day for like 10 hours was play guitar... so i take pride in being about 20% farther along than other people who've been playing the same amout of time =P


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:55 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.