Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Talk Instruments (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/)
-   -   Self Taught?? (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/40554-self-taught.html)

NumberNineDream 08-20-2009 12:35 AM

my friend plays the piano very good ... so she self taught herself the chords by ear ... just hearing them she memorized the sound, attaching it to a key on her piano ... so it must be easy for you.

i've been using some tabs from my favorite songs ... learning the chords one at a time ... hearing some tips and asking for help in case of a problem from my friends who do play the instrument ...

good luck, in finding your way.

J.S.3otR 08-20-2009 12:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roddy (Post 721742)
Completely self taught, been playing drums for 20 years. Had 6 months of lessons about 5 years ago to get some new inspiration, but apart from that I am. Maybe that's why I'm still crap?

either that or you arent very devoted.
how often to you play?

amyrpell 08-24-2009 10:01 AM

yeah
 
yeah

Blazed And Confused 09-08-2009 09:48 PM

drums: self taught for about a year and a half then took lessons for a month and stopped them. i found the lessons were nothing special, basically just told me stuff i could have figured out on my own, except for polyrythyms and some jazz beats i basically could learn by playing stuff from my favorite artists.

guitar: self taught for 3 years then took lessons for 2 months and quit. self taught guitar is pretty easy for me, i always had the passion and drive to learn how to do things so i would basically just teach myself how to make the sounds i want and from their it was just entertainment so i have no reason for a teacher. personally i dont like the idea of a teacher, a mentor would be nice, maybe if he was a guitar virtuoso that i could basically learn beside rather than being told and shown what to do and just mimicking his style.

Garo 09-09-2009 11:06 AM

Guitar:

Now days it's easier to be self taught then before...all you need is on Youtube and you can find a Guitar Pro tab for every song...but...you need to have 2 basic things...Talent and strong will...If you have that, you don't need a teacher...

A good teacher will not teach you how to play music...He or She will teach you how to feel music and help you express yourself through music...

So my conclusion is...you don't need a teacher. You can learn everything just by looking at other people and trying to reproduce what they're doing...(while doing that, you'll probably find some new techniques that you weren't looking for at the time).

You also don't need a teacher for your creativity...you maybe just need a guide...

And this concludes the first 10-12 years of playing guitar...then look for a teacher that's a better guitarist than you are...If you pushed realy hard in the first part, finding someone better than you will be a difficult job, but then you'll know what is still there for you to learn...

(my English is not very good, but I think you understand what I mean...)

made 09-26-2009 02:09 PM

Yeah I find strong will probably the second most important thing to learning any instrument. I taught myself on guitar, practiced about 6 hours a day for a few years.. But then every once in a while someone shows me something on guitar and I'm like I NEVER would have thought of playing that way, rhythm, progression... So playing and learning form other people I think is great too.

tgpo 09-27-2009 10:09 PM

I'm self taught on the bass. I took 2 lessons from a crappy teacher, but once they found out I already knew the basics of how to play, they asked me to bring CDs in and he'd teach me how to play the songs.

So I've got a bad view of music teachers. I say find music you love and learn to play it. If you keep at it, the pieces will fall into place.

kouki 09-28-2009 06:37 PM

I bought the learn and master guitar lessons,pretty expensive,but cheaper then a teacher.Its pretty good.

Jolt 10-02-2009 11:51 PM

Bass: Self taught since last christmas.
Hello Rush :D Haha.
I'm new to BTW

BlitzySixx 10-07-2009 05:12 PM

With all three of the instruments I play, I am in fact self taught. It's definitely much harder but at least you don't have someone yelling at you and complaining. ;)

TingoTingo 10-11-2009 03:09 PM

I learn from a book mainly but once in a while a friend teaches me some stuff.
(guitar)

music_phantom13 10-16-2009 05:21 PM

I took 3 years of piano lessons when I was like 6-9. I sucked back then. But it was enough that now when I look at a piano I see the keys as notes. Now I entirely teach myself, I can read sheet music but I prefer to make things up. I just kind of play things that sound good and it ends up working out. You just have to hear what's coming a few seconds before you get there, if that makes any sense. And the more you play, the more complicated things you will be able to do. It's as easy as that.

Kole 10-16-2009 05:28 PM

I think the best (or maybe the worst?) think that happens to self-taught musicians is that they (we) have a completely unique, own style. Instructors unintentionally force their own style into the playing of their "grasshoppers"; I can't say which one is better, it kinda depends on you.

GuitarBizarre 10-18-2009 08:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kole (Post 753513)
I think the best (or maybe the worst?) think that happens to self-taught musicians is that they (we) have a completely unique, own style. Instructors unintentionally force their own style into the playing of their "grasshoppers"; I can't say which one is better, it kinda depends on you.

Not exactly. it just means they take their style from elsewhere, its not necessarily a good or bad thing, but its just as limiting in the end. And besides, nobody has a 'unique' style on their own. Its kind of pretentious to go around saying 'I am original and unique, a special snowflake', considering a whole bunch of people probably sound very similar to you in the end.

kouki 10-18-2009 08:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 754313)
Its kind of pretentious to go around saying 'I am original and unique, a special snowflake', considering a whole bunch of people probably sound very similar to you in the end.

Very well said,sir.Its pretty difficult IMO to be original nowadays.So much has been done already.

GuitarBizarre 10-18-2009 03:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kouki (Post 754316)
Very well said,sir.Its pretty difficult IMO to be original nowadays.So much has been done already.

You should read up on postmodern musical theories. I'm studying them at university right now and they basically hold that there is NO original music anymore, only different sounding bric-a-brac made from other bits of music.

mr dave 10-18-2009 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 754313)
And besides, nobody has a 'unique' style on their own. Its kind of pretentious to go around saying 'I am original and unique, a special snowflake', considering a whole bunch of people probably sound very similar to you in the end.

but when you've spent the better part of a decade working towards a unique sound and you get proper musicians asking you 'no offense, but do you actually know how to play guitar like a normal person?'. i don't think it's pretentious to say you've managed to develop a unique and original style :p:


and in terms of post-modern theories. yes, all styles draw from other elements, then again if you look back enough all music goes back to the first cavedude who tapped rocks on a log to get some cavechick to dance for him. then again we also live in a heavily categorized society so even when you do manage to create something new someone will create a new sub-genre by mashing a few relatively close styles into a new term, like post-hardcore-freejazz-shoegaze-surf rock... but that's only if you tremolo pick single note leads a lot otherwise it's just post-hardcore-freejazz-shoegaze-garage rock. there's a DIFFERENCE... sub-genres are IMPORTANT... :rofl:

GuitarBizarre 10-18-2009 09:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 754542)
but when you've spent the better part of a decade working towards a unique sound and you get proper musicians asking you 'no offense, but do you actually know how to play guitar like a normal person?'. i don't think it's pretentious to say you've managed to develop a unique and original style :p:


and in terms of post-modern theories. yes, all styles draw from other elements, then again if you look back enough all music goes back to the first cavedude who tapped rocks on a log to get some cavechick to dance for him. then again we also live in a heavily categorized society so even when you do manage to create something new someone will create a new sub-genre by mashing a few relatively close styles into a new term, like post-hardcore-freejazz-shoegaze-surf rock... but that's only if you tremolo pick single note leads a lot otherwise it's just post-hardcore-freejazz-shoegaze-garage rock. there's a DIFFERENCE... sub-genres are IMPORTANT... :rofl:

No, that just means that the person in question hasn't heard anything ELSE that sounds like that. It still more than likely exists.

thomasracer56 10-18-2009 10:36 PM

i'm self teaching myself to play guitar and drums 'cause it's awesome and i wouldn't have to apply playing with a sheet paper to playing by ear. anyways, my elective at school has a teacher for trumpet.

mr dave 10-19-2009 02:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 754757)
No, that just means that the person in question hasn't heard anything ELSE that sounds like that. It still more than likely exists.

well, until someone can name drop a single person that sounds like me i'm gonna keep thinking i achieved uniqueness :p: (besides my comment was supposed to be a funny)

GuitarBizarre 10-19-2009 07:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 754838)
well, until someone can name drop a single person that sounds like me i'm gonna keep thinking i achieved uniqueness :p: (besides my comment was supposed to be a funny)

rarrrr i am srsbiz rar rar!

someonecompletelyrandom 10-19-2009 03:41 PM

I regret the way I've learned music. I went straight from basics to recording and just kept working with myself to get the recordings sounding decent. It sounds like an OK way to learn but I wish I had been able to practice live with other players, something I have a bit of a struggle with now.

kouki 10-19-2009 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 754462)
You should read up on postmodern musical theories. I'm studying them at university right now and they basically hold that there is NO original music anymore, only different sounding bric-a-brac made from other bits of music.

Ya I figured,theres just so much shi* out there.A lot of songs use the same chord progression too,just different rythm.Plus that one song says it too(forgot the name) but it goes something like this "its all been done, whooo uuuu uuuuu its all been done,its all been doooone beforeeee"LMAO *turns off stupid switch*

someonecompletelyrandom 10-19-2009 05:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 754462)
You should read up on postmodern musical theories. I'm studying them at university right now and they basically hold that there is NO original music anymore, only different sounding bric-a-brac made from other bits of music.

That's rediculously narrow-minded. Theres a bit more to music than pop chord progressions and pretentious modern classical quote unquote avant-garde music, which I'm sure is about as far into "weird" music as the morons who wrote those books have delved.

mr dave 10-19-2009 06:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 755071)
That's rediculously narrow-minded. Theres a bit more to music than pop chord progressions and pretentious modern classical quote unquote avant-garde music, which I'm sure is about as far into "weird" music as the morons who wrote those books have delved.

yes and no. even the weird stuff tends to draw from traditional resources in its initial stages. from my perspective it seems that the majority of 'weird' musicians have an idea of where the mainstream flows and where the tributary of weird stuff they like branches off. they're able to recognize the level of deviation between those two elements then tend to apply a similar amount of deviation to their own style from within the established tributary they chose to admire.

as for the recyclability of pop music...


someonecompletelyrandom 10-19-2009 07:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 755133)
yes and no. even the weird stuff tends to draw from traditional resources in its initial stages. from my perspective it seems that the majority of 'weird' musicians have an idea of where the mainstream flows and where the tributary of weird stuff they like branches off. they're able to recognize the level of deviation between those two elements then tend to apply a similar amount of deviation to their own style from within the established tributary they chose to admire.

Using just the basic fundimentals of music this theory is disproven.

There are eight commonly accepted note durations

whole note
half note
quarter note
eighth note
sixteenth note
thirty-second note
sixty-fourth note
hundred twenty-eighth note

Using the familular scale we are all used to, there is available to be combined with these particular lengths:

A
B
C
D
E
F
G

If we were to make just a four note song using the above accessories...without taking into account time signatures, odd notes, dissonant elements, repetition etc..

there are literally endless combinations. It's bollocks to say there is no "new" music being written! It's like saying all books aren't really new, they are just made up of letters from other books.

mr dave 10-20-2009 04:06 AM

you're right from the technical standpoint, but using your book example again, it can be argued that the same basic stories are being told with different characters (man vs. nature / man vs. machine / man vs. self / etc.)

the same applies to pretty much all song based music. the notes and styles might be different but the underlying formulas remain.

you could try breaking free from that and playing improv on purpose for records but Ornette Coleman already beat us all to that one 55 years ago.

while there's certainly more people who chose to listen to the 'weird' stuff on purpose now rather than to be content to simply hear it within some other form of media, it doesn't change the fact that it's pretty much all been done before in one way or another.

Daktari 10-27-2009 03:07 PM

Easy chord sequences to fit hundreds of tunes.
 
Hi there,

I have just been browsing through this section and on a similar subject to the Pachalbel Rant as posted above. The guy has obviously researched and found examples of songs using the same chord sequence as in Pachalbel's canon. If we transpose that up to the key of Gmaj it would be:

G, D, Em, Bm, C, G, Am, D...... and so on and on..... That's what a canon is. A building variation on the same set of chords repeated over and over. And as he demonstrated, there are loads of modern songs that follow that same progression.

For relative beginners who are looking to learn new songs, here are a few more:

G, Em, C, D...... This simple sequence was very, very popular in 1950's and early 60's songs. Might not be the exact same key but the relative chord changes were used many hundreds of times and are still popular today. Two examples: Dream by the Everley Brothers and more recently, One Love by U2.

Right now the most popular sequence of chords is:

G, D, Em, C. Play around with that sequence and it seems like half the stuff on the radio features that very progression. As heard in No Woman, No Cry by the great Bob Marley, Halo by Beyonce and hundreds of others from Taylor Swift to Greenday. It's all just variations on a theme.

As a beginner, if you learn the three above mentioned chord sequences, maybe in a few different keys and you will have a huge collection of songs to go at. With a little time you will be able to recognise all the songs that use them.

All the best, Gordon.:thumb:

jennysimsmusic 10-31-2009 04:40 PM

I'm self taught in guitar (or self teaching) - (singing i suppose too)
I got lessons in piano for a good while, but it didnt interest me as much, i felt it tedious
I find the best option for what I wanted to achieve on guitar was to pick up knowledge and 'skills' from friends and family. Ive never wanted to be a superduper guitar player though, so my methods may not work for everyone haha

I know my brother is learning from himself/family(me and father)/random friends, he picks it all up so fast its astonishing, so it can be done productively

ElephantSack 11-01-2009 02:07 PM

I'm self taught for the most part. My pops showed me the basics of playing bass (a few songs, a scale or two) when I was a kid, and then I pretty much just took it from there. Guitar came pretty naturally after that, just from watching my brother's hands when we would play together. And I've always had a thing for drums. I don't know. One day I just decided to play the drums, and I played the drums. Weird, now that I think about it.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:22 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.