Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Current Events, Philosophy, & Religion (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/)
-   -   How Real Is Christianity? (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/39067-how-real-christianity.html)

Surell 04-23-2009 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SATCHMO (Post 645464)
No don't scratch that. let it stay. That is the great lesson in all thi, isn't it? Burning bibles IS like burning disco.

Well, most people lives changed for the worse when they got into the Disco culture. I think it's more the other way around with people who get into the Christian thing.

But seriously, thought unscratched officially.

The Monkey 04-24-2009 05:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zzz (Post 645460)
Aren't you the same person who said something along the lines of every genre but rock was crap?

No, I said (or at least meant) that I mainly listened to rock.
Quote:

Anyways, what justification do you have for burning the Bible? If you don't stand behind it's teachings, why would you own a copy in the first place? Would you honestly go out and buy a copy for the sake of burning it?
Well, I haven't burned one, I'm talking hypothetically. I wouldn't spend money on anything I was just gonna burn anyway. And justification? I hate what the bible stands for and think it has caused great harm to humanity. Isn't that reason enough?
Quote:

About offending people, it's quite simple. Just because you believe something doesn't always mean you have to say it allowed, unless you're cool with being a total prick (not saying you are, we're talking hypothetically). Same thing applies in this scenario
I repeat, how is it offending if they don't find out? It's not like I would burn it on a public square.

I can't see myself burning a bible, I'm just saying I don't have a problem with the action itself.

pahuuuta 04-24-2009 10:48 AM

how can you say the bible has caused harm to humanity? can you give me three reasons how it has, than ill give you three reasons it hasnt.

Whatsitoosit 04-24-2009 11:03 AM

the penis has caused more harm to humanity then anything else.

pahuuuta 04-24-2009 11:11 AM

STDS have caused more harm to humanity than anything else, ha

Whatsitoosit 04-24-2009 11:31 AM

think about it... why do we cheat? why do we fight wars? why do we leave our families? why do we think we are better then others? start fights, etc...

The bigger d1ck theory.

pahuuuta 04-24-2009 12:59 PM

im not sure i understand what your saying. .

cardboard adolescent 04-24-2009 01:34 PM

all the world's issues boil down to macho insecurity? surely a part of it but probably an oversimplification.

pahuuuta 04-24-2009 01:38 PM

oh i see i see now i agree with that to a certain point

Whatsitoosit 04-24-2009 02:44 PM

all actions cause a re-action... from the beginning of man has humanity been on the decline. Perhaps it's oversimplified... but why does it need to be complex for it to be valid?

SATCHMO 04-24-2009 03:35 PM

This is an excerpt from a book I'm reading Power vs. Force by Richard Dawkins That i think is relevant to the discussion:


"A statement may be true at a high level of understanding, but be incomprehensible to the average mind. Its value may therefor be corrupted when the statement is distorted by the limitations of the listener. This has been the fate of religions through the ages, when pronouncements originating from high levels of awareness were later misinterpreted by followers vested with authority.
Such distortions can be seen in the fundamentalist sects of any religion. The fundamentalist's interpretation of religious teachings stresses negativity, and is removed from this negativity only by truth. The lowest depictions of deity are of a god who is jealous, vengeful, and angry, a god of death far removed from the god of and love. The god of righteous negativity represents a glorification of the negative, and provides for his followers a disavowal of responsibility through justification of human cruelty and mayhem. In general pain and suffering increase as one nears the bottom levels of consciousness.
The truth of each level of consciousness is self-verifying in that each level has its native range of perception, which confirms what's already believed to be true. Thus, everyone feels justified in the viewpoints that underlie his actions and beliefs. That's the inherent danger of all righteousness: Anyone can be righteous, from the killer who justifies his rage, to the ecclesiastic demagogues and political extremists of all persuasions. By distorting context, it's possible to rationalize and justify almost any human behavior. All wars are stated to be righteous by their perpetrators."

Yukon Cornelius 04-25-2009 12:19 PM

Could we just call this thread prove your faith?? Can you? Can I?

People determine how real Christianity is individually, let me know if you feel any different.

mr dave 04-25-2009 04:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yukon Cornelius (Post 646576)
Could we just call this thread prove your faith?? Can you? Can I?

People determine how real Christianity is individually, let me know if you feel any different.

normally when i see you post in these kind of threads i end up shaking my head, this time i'm happy to be on the same page.

personal belief is exactly that, personal. it's not a matter of being able to 'prove' it, but a matter of accepting that you believe in something regardless of what other people think.

99% of religious discussions i've ever participated in have ended up the same way. with a bunch of cowards who don't have the guts to believe in anything calling out those who do in order to cover up their own insecurities. none of the religious people i know have ever tried to force me to adopt their views, they've never tried to bring me into the fold of their beliefs. yet, every single so-called atheist i've met has always challenged my views. they make the claim to not believe in anything but not a single one i've met has actually had the guts to believe in nothing.

as for the initial question of this thread, christianity is as real as the belief of the individual who choose to follow that religion. that's all.

Scarlett O'Hara 04-26-2009 06:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 646696)
as for the initial question of this thread, christianity is as real as the belief of the individual who choose to follow that religion. that's all.

I agree, it's all down to what an individual believes. And those who do have their own reasons for believing. As far as I'm concerned us many who do should not have to constantly justify our beliefs because somebody else demands it. The emotional and spiritual strength from I feel inside can not be described in words. But it can be shared if another person is willing to open their hearts. Many others are not ready to do that, which is absolutely fine.

Kamikazi Kat 04-26-2009 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 646696)
normally when i see you post in these kind of threads i end up shaking my head, this time i'm happy to be on the same page.

personal belief is exactly that, personal. it's not a matter of being able to 'prove' it, but a matter of accepting that you believe in something regardless of what other people think.

99% of religious discussions i've ever participated in have ended up the same way. with a bunch of cowards who don't have the guts to believe in anything calling out those who do in order to cover up their own insecurities. none of the religious people i know have ever tried to force me to adopt their views, they've never tried to bring me into the fold of their beliefs. yet, every single so-called atheist i've met has always challenged my views. they make the claim to not believe in anything but not a single one i've met has actually had the guts to believe in nothing.

as for the initial question of this thread, christianity is as real as the belief of the individual who choose to follow that religion. that's all.

I have no religious beliefs and I'm certainly not like that. I'm more concerned about practical issus then somebody's belief in God. I tend to take a more agnostic approach to the whole God thing. I think the idea of God makes for interesting discussion, but criticizing or getting angry at somebody just because of their belief in God is pointless to me. When I criticize religion, my arguement is not "Believing in God is silly! Thats stupid! You're Stupid!", the actual problems that have resulted from religion are what concern me most. I understand where you are coming from, I see many atheist who are like that as well as many theist that have a similar attitude.

SATCHMO 04-26-2009 02:51 PM

The problem is that atheism is just as much of a religion as any spiritually based world view. Rhetorically speaking, it is a religion that worships at the altar of science and reason, and uses these, in a materialist sense, to justify its own paradigm of thought, just as all religions use whatever resources avail them to justify their own paradigms.
Anywhere we find the act or mindset of justification there is a defensive posture.
Because a spiritually based religion is a faith based paradigm it relies less heavily on justification of its validity. Which is why you there is more of a defensive posture among atheists, and to a much lesser extent agnostics, than you do with adherents of faith based religions. The reason why this does not appear to be so is that zealotry of any kind is an attempt to justify itself through logic and reason rather than not justify itself at all through faith. It is one of those strange ironies that the most outspoken representatives of any world view, the zealots, are most often the ones who model for others their understanding of the respective religion or worldview, yet most often the model that is provided through zealotry brings forth the most distorted version of that model which they seek to represent.

Whatsitoosit 04-27-2009 10:41 AM

I know first hand that the supernatural exists. I have also seen apparitions of christ like figures in real photographs (straight from the developing place). Coincidence? very doubtful, I'm talking arms, robe, belt, head, feet in the sky (taken from a plane). Maybe it was just a spirit from 2000 + years ago and not Jesus himself. I believe energy goes on after death... not sure where it goes, but I don't think it just vanishes. These are the things that keep my faith strong... but then when I start over analyzing that which I can't understand to be true, then my faith starts to lessen. Stories written by man cause me to doubt... I believe there is something out there that we could never fully fathom and nobody truly knows what it is. It's universal to all... not just towards a particular religion.

Blue 04-27-2009 10:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Whatsitoosit (Post 647384)
I know first hand that the supernatural exists.


Do you mind sharing?

coryallen2 04-27-2009 10:58 AM

Is'nt it amazing what we believe and how it runs our lives?

I'd rather not get all into the 'political' or 'religious' talks because they could last days, but im saying in the bible god made everything. Everything is man,women animal universe. He also says their are no other gods or religions. Well what im saying is if he made EVERYTHING why is their buddists and other religions? He had to make those. Also alogn with the subject of only 1 religion, why are their so many religions that worship the shristian god. I mean look at catholics.
What I am proving with this is not that god is real or fake I am proving that all of this religion stuff is corrupt i mean half of the hebrew language couldnt be translated in those times and when the roman empire fell alot of scrolls and artifacts were destroyed.
So do you believe that there was a "the end" page there or are you people goign to center yourselves around a corrupt empire of lonleyness?
And by the way Holy,religious people whatever you want to call them are some of the nastyest meanest peopel out there.
Thats why I choose to keep myself away from it.

Whatsitoosit 04-27-2009 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blue (Post 647386)
Do you mind sharing?

after my grandmother died in 1985, my brother and I held a little seance in our bedroom. We sat there together with candles lit, lights out and just asked for some form of sign if my grandmother was listening or in the room with us. Sure enough within' 30 seconds or so we heard the cover to a chest we had in the room SLAM shut. This thing had hinges on it and was not easy to close, you had to put some force into it. Anyway... we both jumped up and ran out of the room. We did it again at my other grandmothers house and again, after we asked for a sign we heard something fall and start to move. It was our Verbot (a robot toy from the 80's) that suddenly switched on then fell off the table.

About 5 years later my grandfather fell ill with lung cancer and was dying in our home as being in a hospital wouldn't have done him any good by this point. Anyway, I was sleeping over a friends house (not really thinking about him passing away that weekend or anytime soon). That night I had a dream of my grandfather in a blue suit waving to me. He was in the distance with a bright white light behind him and he just stood there waving. I knew it was him but didn't know why I was dreaming this. When my father picked me up he told me that my grandfather had passed away the night before but they didn't want to tell me because they didn't see the point since I was having fun at my friends house. When I went to the wake my grandfather was in a blue suit... it freaked me out. Later my mother told me she had the very same dream, woke up... went to the bathroom, came out to check on my grandfather, he made a funny sound and died.

I've heard tons of other stories from people that wouldn't lie about that sorta thing... I know there are forces and spirits around us.

Freebase Dali 04-28-2009 01:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wayfarer (Post 647717)
think*

More to the point:
Forces that seem supernatural, but are really a result of ignorant fools who scare themselves so much with their own c0ckeyed beliefs they actually believe they're experiencing what they're imagining.

I hang my head low.
And I shake it slowly.

SATCHMO 04-28-2009 02:00 AM

"Supernatural" is a contradiction in terms. We just havent fully understood the scientific basis for a lot of metaphysical happenings. Well we have, it just isn't common knowledge yet.

Freebase Dali 04-28-2009 02:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SATCHMO (Post 647780)
"Supernatural" is a contradiction in terms. We just havent fully understood the scientific basis for a lot of metaphysical happenings. Well we have, it just isn't common knowledge yet.

As Socrates would say: Tru dat.

But I think we're a long way off from having a scientific explanation for the claims of ghost sightings.
Edit: I mean that in the way of proof of ghosts, not explanations for people "seeing" them.

333 04-28-2009 02:11 AM

Look you guys, V and SATCH ... Hangin' with the grown-ups in the religion section ..

SATCHMO 04-28-2009 02:16 AM

Ooh, it's awfully pious in here.

Freebase Dali 04-28-2009 02:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 333 (Post 647791)
Look you guys, V and SATCH ... Hangin' with the grown-ups in the religion section ..

I know, can you believe it?
I'm usually too slutty at this time of night.

SATCHMO 04-28-2009 02:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veridical Fiction (Post 647794)
I know, can you believe it?
I'm usually too slutty at this time of night.

:pimp: Bitch better have my money before you start gettin' all churchy on me!

Freebase Dali 04-28-2009 02:19 AM

lol. You're such the opportunist.

SATCHMO 04-28-2009 02:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veridical Fiction (Post 647797)
lol. You're such the opportunist.

:pimp: I needs to get paid!

Whatsitoosit 04-28-2009 09:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wayfarer (Post 647717)
think*

know*

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veridical Fiction (Post 647774)
More to the point:
Forces that seem supernatural, but are really a result of ignorant fools who scare themselves so much with their own c0ckeyed beliefs they actually believe they're experiencing what they're imagining.

I hang my head low.
And I shake it slowly.

I gave 3 very real examples of my own proof as basis for believing, fool.

pahuuuta 04-28-2009 09:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Whatsitoosit (Post 647408)
after my grandmother died in 1985, my brother and I held a little seance in our bedroom. We sat there together with candles lit, lights out and just asked for some form of sign if my grandmother was listening or in the room with us. Sure enough within' 30 seconds or so we heard the cover to a chest we had in the room SLAM shut. This thing had hinges on it and was not easy to close, you had to put some force into it. Anyway... we both jumped up and ran out of the room. We did it again at my other grandmothers house and again, after we asked for a sign we heard something fall and start to move. It was our Verbot (a robot toy from the 80's) that suddenly switched on then fell off the table.

About 5 years later my grandfather fell ill with lung cancer and was dying in our home as being in a hospital wouldn't have done him any good by this point. Anyway, I was sleeping over a friends house (not really thinking about him passing away that weekend or anytime soon). That night I had a dream of my grandfather in a blue suit waving to me. He was in the distance with a bright white light behind him and he just stood there waving. I knew it was him but didn't know why I was dreaming this. When my father picked me up he told me that my grandfather had passed away the night before but they didn't want to tell me because they didn't see the point since I was having fun at my friends house. When I went to the wake my grandfather was in a blue suit... it freaked me out. Later my mother told me she had the very same dream, woke up... went to the bathroom, came out to check on my grandfather, he made a funny sound and died.

I've heard tons of other stories from people that wouldn't lie about that sorta thing... I know there are forces and spirits around us.


maybe so but there are also things called coincidence

Whatsitoosit 04-28-2009 10:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pahuuuta (Post 648023)
maybe so but there are also things called coincidence

a 12 year old dreaming of his grandfather (prior to knowing of his death) waving goodbye in the suit (which I've never seen prior) he would be buried in? it's reaching pretty far to say coincidence, but if that helps your argument... sure, coincidence. I don't think so.

Also, twice, things slamming shut or falling on command from calling out the same dead relative could also be a coincidence. Believe it or not, something else is out there and it's easy to not think so... but when it faces you, you'd have to have your head up your butt to not acknowledge it. I'm guessing for those that think it's nonsense it never faced them... I understand that, I wouldn't believe it either.

This I don't expect anybody to believe but the person who told it to me is one of the most honest people I've ever encountered. Him and his friends were playing with a ouija board when they were younger on a very heavy metal table. They eventually asked the spirit they summoned to raise the table and the table began to rise to the point where they all had to stand while keeping there hands on the table. They all looked at each other and said "ok, who's doing this?" but the table was too heavy for somebody to be pretending to lift it. Eventually the table just slammed to the ground and that was the last time they fooled with the ouija board. Think that is a coincidence? I don't.

Guybrush 04-28-2009 11:01 AM

Before you rely too much on human experience, you should know what humans are capable of in regards to suggestion, placebos etc. We affect ourselves more than you might think. In another thread, I posted a vid where they set up a fake ghost story, then get unkowing mediums to investigate it. One of the mediums actually gets posessed by the fake ghost (named George Bull for "bull****") and actually thinks she has a real "possession" experience.

I don't think it's unlikely at all that people who try out ouija for example feel like they have some kind of paranormal experience. Especially if you throw a little fear into the mix, people can imagine or "suggest" to themselves some rather weird things. Would the ghosts or demons be there when the sun is out and the birds are singing though?

I've also had "paranormal" experiences, but I don't think of them as such. I think it was a mixture of fear and other things leading to mind tricks.


Also, a thing about coincidence is that if you are to take 6 numbers at random between 1 and a million, the chance of getting 1 every time is just as high as getting a sequence of different numbers. Many people don't understand probability and humans have a highly developed ability to make associations where there are none, such as associating the slamming of a door with an unknown presence. Put people in a "ghost house", let the wind close a door - they might believe it was a ghost.

coryallen2 04-28-2009 11:06 AM

http://www.moonslipper.com/images/ghost07.jpg


OoOoOoOoO



How did we go from god to ghosts?

Blue 04-28-2009 11:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Whatsitoosit (Post 648077)
Believe it or not, something else is out there and it's easy to not think so... but when it faces you, you'd have to have your head up your butt to not acknowledge it. I'm guessing for those that think it's nonsense it never faced them... I understand that, I wouldn't believe it either.

I've been faced by things that I think could possibly be interpreted as supernatural, but I'm still not convinced that they are. I've been in situations where I think people would interpret it as a sign from "God" or some sort of religious, paranormal, supernatural experience, but I don't necessarily see it as such (though I see why people could interpret it in that way). I guess I'm not ruling it out, but we can make ourselves believe anything and I guess I kind of stand in line with this....

Quote:

I've also had "paranormal" experiences, but I don't think of them as such. I think it was a mixture of fear and other things leading to mind tricks.

Whatsitoosit 04-28-2009 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 648100)
Before you rely too much on human experience, you should know what humans are capable of in regards to suggestion, placebos etc. We affect ourselves more than you might think. In another thread, I posted a vid where they set up a fake ghost story, then get unkowing mediums to investigate it. One of the mediums actually gets posessed by the fake ghost (named George Bull for "bull****") and actually thinks she has a real "possession" experience.

I don't think it's unlikely at all that people who try out ouija for example feel like they have some kind of paranormal experience. Especially if you throw a little fear into the mix, people can imagine or "suggest" to themselves some rather weird things. Would the ghosts or demons be there when the sun is out and the birds are singing though?

I've also had "paranormal" experiences, but I don't think of them as such. I think it was a mixture of fear and other things leading to mind tricks.


Also, a thing about coincidence is that if you are to take 6 numbers at random between 1 and a million, the chance of getting 1 every time is just as high as getting a sequence of different numbers. Many people don't understand probability and humans have a highly developed ability to make associations where there are none, such as associating the slamming of a door with an unknown presence. Put people in a "ghost house", let the wind close a door - they might believe it was a ghost.

knowing the nature of the said items that slammed shut and suddenly turned on and fell, it's hard to fathom it was just mind tricks and that would have happened regardless of what we were doing at the time. It has never happened before or after this experience, only during at the very moment we asked it to happen. Sh1t, I wish everything was like that... "send me a million bucks" POOF!!! wow, a million bucks!! must be a coincidence :)

I could have subconsciously dreamed of my grandfather waving goodbye knowing he was dying of cancer... but how do you explain him being in the same suit he would be buried in? a suit I've never seen prior? and being a day after he actually died? did I just happen to be thinking of the color blue at the time and coincidentally he had just died and would be in that suit? again... I need to start playing the lottery now, I have some good mind trick abilities :)

I know the whole ouija board theory has been debunked several times, the table raising story is different then people moving a game piece around the board with there hands.

Quote:

Originally Posted by coryallen2 (Post 648102)
How did we go from god to ghosts?

a similar subject I think.

chard 04-28-2009 12:25 PM

Since becoming a christian im no longer afraid of death.So its become real for me,and for that reason alone i take more risks and my life is a little out of control at times. Which after all, a spice of life.I cant say i depend on god. Though i feel a sense of friendship if that makes any sense.Im never alone even on the toilet lol.

Blue 04-28-2009 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chard (Post 648183)
Since becoming a christian im no longer afraid of death.So its become real for me,and for that reason alone i take more risks and my life is a little out of control at times. Which after all, a spice of life.I cant say i depend on god. Though i feel a sense of friendship if that makes any sense.Im never alone even on the toilet lol.

Not that I want to criticize your way of life, because I think everyone is entitled to living their life in their own way as long as it doesn't impede on someone elses, but, I think the reality that we're all very much alone and always will be is something we all have to at least consider (and in my opinion, accept) because that's just the way it could be.

Thrice 04-28-2009 12:40 PM

Id like to see some modern day miracles, some red sea parting, some water walking, etc....then ask me how real christianity is.

chard 04-28-2009 01:14 PM

Is there a place like a forest or a beach could be anywhere really that has history a place in which sane people wouldnt tread at night and stay there on your own for 12 hours.I tell you this theres a good chance your see a miracle.Halleluya i believe lol.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:20 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.