|
|||||||
| Register | Blogging | Today's Posts | Search |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
|
#10 (permalink) | |||
|
Juicious Maximus III
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Scabb Island
Posts: 6,525
|
Quote:
What the author means is that whatever it is in our biology that makes us have a capacity to create and enjoy music is still evolving - as in the genetic makeup that code for those traits are still changing with each generation and he's saying, perhaps a bit clumsily, that people with musical skill on average have higher fitness today than the non-musical. Genres and culture is not part of that statement. It's about evolving DNA. When he's writing about the evolution of music, what he means is the evolution of man's cacapity and desire to create and listen to music and the role that it plays from an evolutional point of view. Why did it evolve and is it still evolving for the same reason? You write stuff like how music was made to appease the gods. If you knew anything about evolution at all, you would know that appeasing the gods, unless they actually exist and reward you with sex, is not something that will reward you with increased fitness. And so, as an argument against evolution, it's completely worthless. The point of the authors is that in our history, and this is something that would have gone on for thousands upon thousands of years, musical people have had higher fitness. They've on average had more offspring. Their suggested explanation is that women find men who are musical more attractive. The reason it's women who find men attractive and not vice versa is because females, carrying babies around in their bodies who use their resources and then feeding them milk after birth, have a tremendously high parental input into offspring compared to what men can get away with and so they have to make sure they get good sexual partners. Men can shoot their load and take off. In evolution, this is extremely important and has far reaching consequences. If you really think that music is not evolving, you should make a proper argument that has to do with evolution. And, just so you know, mankind never stops evolving and so claiming music doesn't evolve will automatically make you wrong. Now, the reason I call you stupid is really because you come here, don't know what the hell the thread is about, posts like you think you do and then do it in the douchiest, most pretentious way possible, suggesting Pedestrian through away the book as you know better, claiming the authors are wrong and trying to score cred by boasting about your psychology minor. If that's not being a stupid, douchy idiot, I don't know what is. No, but I am a biologist with a master's degree in biology so I've studied evolution and so, unlike you, understand the subject of the thread. edit : Quote:
Quote:
__________________
Something Completely Different Last edited by Guybrush; 12-01-2011 at 10:53 AM. |
|||
|
|
|
|
|