sopsych

Did Humans Invent Music? - Gary Marcus & Geoffrey Miller - Entertainment - The Atlantic

I believe there was a long thread about a similar topic. Maybe this belongs there, but I don't know how to find it.

Lisnaholic

It`s an interesting article, wisdom, and one of the comments at the end had a link that led me to this intriguing clip :-



Thanks !

__________________
"Am I enjoying this moment? I know of it and perhaps that is enough." - Sybille Bedford, 1953

Dr_Rez

So a bunch of elephants hit something in front of them that makes noise....why is that surprising??

__________________
*Best chance of losing virginity is in prison crew*
*Always Checks Credentials Crew*
*nba > nfl crew*
*Shave one of my legs to pretend its a girl in my bed crew*

Lisnaholic

What surprises me are the elements of control, co-ordination and rhythm that the elephants are displaying. They aren`t walking away, or knocking their instruments over. And the big guy in the centre hitting the drums, for instance, is delivering a consistent beat. The only apparent reward for his efforts is pleasure, or at least curiosity, about the sound that he`s making. So, does that mean that he`s a musician ?

I guess that was the question in the back of my mind when I said, "intriguing".

__________________
"Am I enjoying this moment? I know of it and perhaps that is enough." - Sybille Bedford, 1953

Dr_Rez

They have also probably been trained and done it many times before. Not to mention the musicians are helping them by playing lots of other instruments. An animal has a heart beat just like us so I dont see why its wierd they would hit something at that tempo.

You do know the average tempo for the majority of popular music is typically similar to ones heart beat, its not a mystery. Us and all other living things like the pace and rhythm of our hearts.

__________________
*Best chance of losing virginity is in prison crew*
*Always Checks Credentials Crew*
*nba > nfl crew*
*Shave one of my legs to pretend its a girl in my bed crew*

Zaqarbal

"Did Humans Invent Music?"

Keyword: Invent. That is, we're talking about creating something new. Which is different than an inborn ability, like this one:



Anyway, animals and humans have, at least, one thing in common: males making music in order to attract females' attention.

__________________

Neapolitan

Marcus Miller

Interesting, I have to reread it before commenting.

__________________

Key

Humans invented music.

Aliens invented dubstep.

PostParadiseUK

Yes. Since I assume it wasn't dinosaurs.

Key

Well, it's definitely possible: