Grateful dead vs. Phish

KillerForHire · 12-14-2013, 02:30 AM

I know this is an old debate but i've only ever had it with one die hard phish fan who hated the grateful dead and i am a die hard grateful dead fan who is not a phish fan, he likes to try to compare the two and say phish is better and I don't think there remotely similar, it's like comparing the B 52's with funkadelic. im not saying the grateful dead is better, im just saying there not comparible, am I wrong???

Gavin B. · 12-14-2013, 06:57 AM

I agree that the Grateful Dead in their prime was a far more innovative and groundbreaking band than Phish. Phish simply lacks strength in the songwriting department and can't compete with the Grateful Dead's massive catalog of great songs written by Jerry Garcia & Robert Hunter.

To be fair, Farmhouse (2000) an album which Phish outsourced their songwriting duties to songwriter/keyboardist Tom Marshall is the strongest Phish studio album to date. However many Phish fans revile Farmhouse because it lacks the usual 15 or 20 minute jam songs that are the heart of Phish's live concert repertoire.

12-14-2013, 02:30 AM	#1 (permalink)
KillerForHire Groupie Join Date: Dec 2013 Posts: 8	Grateful dead vs. Phish I know this is an old debate but i've only ever had it with one die hard phish fan who hated the grateful dead and i am a die hard grateful dead fan who is not a phish fan, he likes to try to compare the two and say phish is better and I don't think there remotely similar, it's like comparing the B 52's with funkadelic. im not saying the grateful dead is better, im just saying there not comparible, am I wrong???

12-14-2013, 06:57 AM	#2 (permalink)
Gavin B. Model Worker Join Date: Jan 2009 Posts: 1,248	I agree that the Grateful Dead in their prime was a far more innovative and groundbreaking band than Phish. Phish simply lacks strength in the songwriting department and can't compete with the Grateful Dead's massive catalog of great songs written by Jerry Garcia & Robert Hunter. To be fair, Farmhouse (2000) an album which Phish outsourced their songwriting duties to songwriter/keyboardist Tom Marshall is the strongest Phish studio album to date. However many Phish fans revile Farmhouse because it lacks the usual 15 or 20 minute jam songs that are the heart of Phish's live concert repertoire. __________________ There are two types of music: the first type is the blues and the second type is all the other stuff. Townes Van Zandt