Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   A question to vegetarians (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/34930-question-vegetarians.html)

Howard the Duck 06-07-2011 09:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1065661)
As a biologist, I have to correct here .. What you probably mean is that it only happens to arthropods. Spiders and scorpions for example are not insects! :)

But that observation still doesn't explain why God didn't just make it easier if he/she/it intended them to be et in the first place.

i stand corrected

maybe God thought it's more fun having the humans to chase after prey

a girl who wants pursuit is more interesting than a girl who just takes you on just like that - if you want an analogy

edit :- at any rate, I don't see traditionally domicile animals for meat (pig, sheep and cows) running away or putting up much of a fight, they just stand there for slaughter

Guybrush 06-07-2011 09:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Il Duce (Post 1065662)
edit :- at any rate, I don't see traditionally domicile animals for meat (pig, sheep and cows) running away or putting up much of a fight, they just stand there for slaughter

Cattle, sheep and pigs do tend to be less afraid than their wilder cousins (although many are still weary of people, there's just not much they can do about it standing in a pen). Most people will know this is because we have selected for friendlier animals, just like we've selected for cows that give more milk, hens that lay more eggs, dogs that are loyal and good at specific tasks etc. It's something that's been done for thousands of years and the observation that it is at all possible for animals to inherit from their parents a tendency to be nicer, bigger, of a specific colour etc. was one of the major observations supporting Darwin's theory of evolution ..

But it still doesn't explain why animals in the wild run away if they're intended to be our food .. Unless it is as you write; that God want us to be stimulated and have a little excercise. :p:

The Virgin 06-07-2011 09:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paloma (Post 1065602)
Then that would make it okay for me not to eat meat, wouldn't it.

By your IRREFUTABLE LOGIC

i doubt that you don't eat meat. no single person on earth have not tasted even just one spoon of meat in their lifetime. that would be ridiculous.

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1065641)
The Virgin, if the intention of an edible animal like a deer for example is to be our food, then why are they generally so eager to escape the hunter? Why don't they just come running to us when we're hungry?

yes it is God's intention that some animals are meant for human consumption that let us not forget, even animals have free will. either they want to pursue what's planned for them or not.
same as with mankind, God wanted us to eat those animals he cretaed for us but he also gave us the free will if we want it or not. if you don't want to be healthy, go ahead, skip on meat.

Guybrush 06-07-2011 09:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1065677)
yes it is God's intention that some animals are meant for human consumption that let us not forget, even animals have free will. either they want to pursue what's planned for them or not.
same as with mankind, God wanted us to eat those animals he cretaed for us but he also gave us the free will if we want it or not. if you don't want to be healthy, go ahead, skip on meat.

I asked earlier - what about all the poisonous creepy crawlies which are dangerous and hostile to us - did God create them to be our food as well? You wrote that no, they were created by humans. Could you elaborate on that? Who created them, when, where, how?


Sansa Stark 06-07-2011 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1065677)
i doubt that you don't eat meat. no single person on earth have not tasted even just one spoon of meat in their lifetime. that would be ridiculous.



yes it is God's intention that some animals are meant for human consumption that let us not forget, even animals have free will. either they want to pursue what's planned for them or not.
same as with mankind, God wanted us to eat those animals he cretaed for us but he also gave us the free will if we want it or not. if you don't want to be healthy, go ahead, skip on meat.

No, I don't eat meat. That's why I'm a vegetarian. I'm pretty sure that that was already covered. However, there are plenty of people who were vegetarians since they were small children, and they had vegetarian parents.

So are you really this ignorant or are you trolling

The Batlord 06-07-2011 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1065556)
anything that's for human food is ok no matter what it is, be it an animal or anything.

http://174.120.103.90/images-somethi...d-cannibal.jpg

hip hop bunny hop 06-07-2011 04:03 PM

Quote:

So, if someone is wanting to put on lean muscle mass, such a person might have a good argument for eating a fish that has washed up onto shore and thus died of natural causes! (I'm trying to relate our conversation to the original poster's question. )

However, I wonder whether the 40:40:20 rule truly *is* the best ratio of protein:carbohydrates:fat calories to eat to put on lean muscle mass. Do bodybuilders who eat beans and grains for protein actually *have* a harder time putting on lean muscle mass than meat-eating bodybuilders?
I suppose if they you had vegan bodybuilder (Y) and omnivore bodybuilder (A), and they had the same protein & calorie intake & exercise... yeah, they may be able to put on muscle at a similar rate.

I do know that protein dense, lean meat (tuna, chicken breast) does require the body to burn calories to process it. I don't know if a protein dense vegetarian meal would have the same effect. And, although people often say that beans & rice is a great source of protein, would the vegetarian have to use more variety of grains to have the same effects on the body?

The Virgin 06-08-2011 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1065679)
I asked earlier - what about all the poisonous creepy crawlies which are dangerous and hostile to us - did God create them to be our food as well? You wrote that no, they were created by humans. Could you elaborate on that? Who created them, when, where, how?

not all animals are meant for human consumption. some are meant for human amusement.
there, i answered your question. hope it's now clear to you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paloma (Post 1065761)
No, I don't eat meat. That's why I'm a vegetarian. I'm pretty sure that that was already covered. However, there are plenty of people who were vegetarians since they were small children, and they had vegetarian parents.

So are you really this ignorant or are you trolling

yes i know what's a vegetarian. and no i'm not ignorant and i'm not trolling as well.
all i'm pointing out here is that sometimes, vegetarians tend to be vegetarians not because they love eating vegetables but because they disfavor animal slaughter for food. which i find senseless by the way. it's normal for an animal to be slaughtered and cooked so it will be made edible to a human. you don't expect humans to be like lions chasing pigs around then eat them raw. that would be called cannibalism.

hope i cleared your confused mind too Paloma

Burning Down 06-08-2011 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1066362)
yes i know what's a vegetarian. and no i'm not ignorant and i'm not trolling as well.
all i'm pointing out here is that sometimes, vegetarians tend to be vegetarians not because they love eating vegetables but because they disfavor animal slaughter for food. which i find senseless by the way. it's normal for an animal to be slaughtered and cooked so it will be made edible to a human. you don't expect humans to be like lions chasing pigs around then eat them raw. that would be called cannibalism.

Um, that's not what cannibalism is, just FYI.

Anyways, yes vegetarians are making a conscious choice to not eat animals, and it is generally for the reason that they think animal slaughter is wrong. There are also vegetarians who used to be meat eaters. There's also people who don't eat meat for dietary reasons (too much cholesterol, fat, etc). Sure it is normal for humans to kill animals for food, that's how we've always eaten. But now there are so many varieties of food out there and people are allowed to choose which foods they want to eat. Just as you choose to eat meat, another person can choose not to eat meat. Not senseless at all, in my opinion.

FRED HALE SR. 06-08-2011 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1066362)
not all animals are meant for human consumption. some are meant for human amusement.
there, i answered your question. hope it's now clear to you.



yes i know what's a vegetarian. and no i'm not ignorant and i'm not trolling as well.
all i'm pointing out here is that sometimes, vegetarians tend to be vegetarians not because they love eating vegetables but because they disfavor animal slaughter for food. which i find senseless by the way. it's normal for an animal to be slaughtered and cooked so it will be made edible to a human. you don't expect humans to be like lions chasing pigs around then eat them raw. that would be called cannibalism.

hope i cleared your confused mind too Paloma

Hope he cleared that up for your confused mind Paloma. LOL :rofl: Lions eating pigs? Cannibalism. LOL :rofl:

SATCHMO 06-08-2011 12:24 PM

I'm a situationalist vegan/raw foodist, which means that I'm a vegan except when the situation calls for me to eat animal products. For example, if I'm invited to dinner at a person's house and dinner consists of animal products, I will eat them, but not gluttonously. There's no sense getting on a soapbox about my political/environmental/nutritional beliefs and being rude when someone has been so gracious as to make me dinner. There have also been times in my life when my preferred diet has not been possible to strictly maintain, no big deal.

Having said all this, there's no reason for any human in contemporary times to eat animal products other than the fact that one believes that they taste good, they don't have access to non-animal foods, or they cannot afford to have an animal product free diet. Eating healthy is expensive.

Eating animal products does not provide the nutrition that the body needs to thrive (not even bioavailable protein). Factory farming of animals and their byproducts is a waste of space, global resources, and is in itself and act of cruelty. I care far less about the act of killing an animal than I am concerned about the treatment an animal receives while being raised and the conditions that it is exposed to. Finally, eating animal products, with few exceptions is simply bad for the human body. It causes inflamation, constipation, throws the body's PH balance into a very acidic state, and most animal flesh cooked is almost completely devoid of nutritional value, and the act of cooking flesh introduces carcinogenic substances into the body that are not present in it's uncooked state (although, I will admit that I'd take less nutritionally viable and carcinogenic over replete with food-born diseases).

I think furthest down on the list of reasons why I don't eat animal products is the belief that killing animals is wrong, but I do believe that killing/enslaving animals for no reason is wrong. However, If an animal died of natural causes, I would take part in eat it if it were presented to me graciously.

Sansa Stark 06-08-2011 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1066367)
Hope he cleared that up for your confused mind Paloma. LOL :rofl: Lions eating pigs? Cannibalism. LOL :rofl:

I can't even with this kid

He's not ignorant yet cannibalism is lions eating pigs

I can't even

The Batlord 06-08-2011 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1066362)
not all animals are meant for human consumption. some are meant for human amusement.

You would know, wouldn't you? Now dance, monkey, DANCE!

The Virgin 06-08-2011 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Burning Down (Post 1066365)
Um, that's not what cannibalism is, just FYI.

i'm not sure if they already have a term for animals but i know that cannibalism is when a human being eats another human being. but i'm sure its the same thing as when an animal eats another animal lets say a lion eating a pig, they're both animals, so in a sense it's cannibalism. english is not my first language so if you already invented a term for animals eating animals, then let me know. as for now, i'm gonna use the term cannibalism which is appropriate for my current state of knowledge.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 1066386)
You would know, wouldn't you? Now dance, monkey, DANCE!

that's just downright racism. i'm beginning to think you have a crush on me. first you put my quote in your signature. now you want me to dance, perhaps like a stripper kind of way. sorry pal, i'm taken already.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paloma (Post 1066385)
I can't even with this kid

He's not ignorant yet cannibalism is lions eating pigs

I can't even

see my previous response to burning down

Guybrush 06-08-2011 01:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1066432)
i'm not sure if they already have a term for animals but i know that cannibalism is when a human being eats another human being. but i'm sure its the same thing as when an animal eats another animal lets say a lion eating a pig, they're both animals, so in a sense it's cannibalism. english is not my first language so if you already invented a term for animals eating animals, then let me know. as for now, i'm gonna use the term cannibalism which is appropriate for my current state of knowledge.

For an act of meat consumption to be cannibalism as per usual definitions, both the eater and the eaten has to be of the same species of animal. Human is one species, lion is a another species and pig yet another. A pig eating a pig would be cannibalism. A human eating a human would be cannibalism. A lion eating a lion would be cannibalism.

A lion eating a pig is not necessarily a cannibal, just a lion eating a pig ;)

The Batlord 06-08-2011 01:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1066432)
i'm not sure if they already have a term for animals but i know that cannibalism is when a human being eats another human being. but i'm sure its the same thing as when an animal eats another animal lets say a lion eating a pig, they're both animals, so in a sense it's cannibalism. english is not my first language so if you already invented a term for animals eating animals, then let me know. as for now, i'm gonna use the term cannibalism which is appropriate for my current state of knowledge.

Cannibalism only applies when it's two beings of the same species. "Animals" is not a species. A lion eating another lion is cannibalism. A lion eating a pig is just a lion eating a pig.

Quote:

that's just downright racism. i'm beginning to think you have a crush on me. first you put my quote in your signature. now you want me to dance, perhaps like a stripper kind of way. sorry pal, i'm taken already.
Racist? I don't even know what race you are. I was just being condescending.

Burning Down 06-08-2011 01:56 PM

Humans are animals (although we don't think of ourselves as such), and if cannibalism meant eating any other animal (not just your own species), then we'd all be cannibals.

Sansa Stark 06-08-2011 02:03 PM

Good god stop being such a stereotype, NOBODY has a crush on you

Shoebox 06-08-2011 04:08 PM

I'm not planning on becoming a vegetarian, for that I like the taste of meat too much, but I want to change my eating habits. Not only is meat very expensive in Norway, it is also rather unhealthy. The problem is that I'm so used to eating meals containing meat that I hardly know how to make any meat-free dinners. Salad, soup?

When I move out, I'm going to look for new recipes and try to make more vegetarian dishes. And replace some of the meat with seafood like fish and prawns. Right now I'm living with my parents and I happily except everything I'm served.

Howard the Duck 06-08-2011 09:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1066362)
not all animals are meant for human consumption. some are meant for human amusement.
there, i answered your question. hope it's now clear to you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 1066386)
You would know, wouldn't you? Now dance, monkey, DANCE!

he has a point ya know, look at the circus, obviously lions are meant to jump through hoops of fire and elephants are meant to dance for us

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paloma (Post 1066443)
Good god stop being such a stereotype, NOBODY has a crush on you

he just dunked some philipino fly

The Virgin 06-08-2011 09:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Il Duce (Post 1066792)
he has a point ya know, look at the circus, obviously lions are meant to jump through hoops of fire and elephants are meant to dance for us

exactly my point.
thanks

Quote:

Originally Posted by Il Duce (Post 1066792)
he just dunked some philipino fly

i don't know what this metaphors about but the spelling is incorrect, its Filipino.

Sansa Stark 06-08-2011 09:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shoebox (Post 1066536)
I'm not planning on becoming a vegetarian, for that I like the taste of meat too much, but I want to change my eating habits. Not only is meat very expensive in Norway, it is also rather unhealthy. The problem is that I'm so used to eating meals containing meat that I hardly know how to make any meat-free dinners. Salad, soup?

When I move out, I'm going to look for new recipes and try to make more vegetarian dishes. And replace some of the meat with seafood like fish and prawns. Right now I'm living with my parents and I happily except everything I'm served.

VegWeb.com - Vegan Recipes and Cooking Tips is a valuable resource, just change the vegan versions of things to vegetarian :)
Meatless Monday | one day a week, cut out meat has a great section for recipes

Or if you want to be a fancy ass motha****a
Vegetarian Recipes at Epicurious.com
their stuff is delicious

Howard the Duck 06-08-2011 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1066798)
exactly my point.
thanks



i don't know what this metaphors about but the spelling is incorrect, its Filipino.

boy doesn't know sarcasm

chipper 06-12-2011 08:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Il Duce (Post 1065657)
i have read before that some animals suffer from depression and commit suicide

yes. Tarsier does...

The Virgin 06-12-2011 10:04 AM

and some goats pretend they're dead when they're depressed or stressed

Guybrush 06-12-2011 10:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1069040)
and some goats pretend they're dead when they're depressed or stressed

Really? What kind of goats would that be?

The Virgin 06-12-2011 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1069049)
Really? What kind of goats would that be?

all kinds of goats. i can't paste a link here to support what i said due to my bad internet but you can google it up. it's actually very known.

Mykonos 06-12-2011 04:17 PM

Have meat levels in diets been discussed yet? Throughout most of history the average human has had a mostly carbohydrate-based diet with only very small amounts of meat that weren't taken daily. It's only in recent years that meat consumption has shot up, and not only is it making people fatter, but it's damaging the planet and making energy gains far less efficient. I'm not saying eating meat is bad, but there's certainly too much being eaten.

Paedantic Basterd 06-12-2011 04:20 PM

I've heard of fainting goats. Seen them do it too. Dunno how they slipped by Darwin.

Peacocks who've had their plumage plucked will become depressed and starve themselves to death. While we're talking about animal suicide.

Guybrush 06-12-2011 04:37 PM

Good lord ..

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Virgin (Post 1069073)
all kinds of goats. i can't paste a link here to support what i said due to my bad internet but you can google it up. it's actually very known.

If it's very well known, I should know about it, really. And I've never heard of goats who feign death when depressed.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedestrian (Post 1069194)
I've heard of fainting goats. Seen them do it too. Dunno how they slipped by Darwin.

They're not fainting, their muscles stiffen when they get scared and they fall over, unable to move. I'm not entirely sure what the physiology behind it is, but it's "slipped by" Darwin because it's a mutation which has been selected for by people, like floppy ears or a twirly tail on dogs. In other words, it's not an adaptation or a trait that would survive in nature.

Paedantic Basterd 06-12-2011 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1069204)
They're not fainting, their muscles stiffen when they get scared and they fall over, unable to move. I'm not entirely sure what the physiology behind it is, but it's "slipped by" Darwin because it's a mutation which has been selected for by people, like floppy ears or a twirly tail on dogs. In other words, it's not an adaptation or a trait that would survive in nature.

Haha, yes, I was referring to them as they are colloquially known by... the internet, really. I'm curious as to what benefit these goats present to human beings so as to farm them. Other than youtube fodder.

Guybrush 06-12-2011 04:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedestrian (Post 1069205)
Haha, yes, I was referring to them as they are colloquially known by... the internet, really. I'm curious as to what benefit these goats present to human beings so as to farm them.

They're amusing and very easy to catch.

The Virgin 06-13-2011 07:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1069204)
If it's very well known, I should know about it, really. And I've never heard of goats who feign death when depressed.

nevertheless, goats are tasty meals. my mom always cook one with a dish called "Kalderetang Kanding"... yum yum!

http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5135/...37f55b7d39.jpg

Scarlett O'Hara 06-13-2011 07:10 AM

^ Sounds like a Missy Elliot song. :laughing:

The Virgin 06-13-2011 07:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vanilla (Post 1069462)
^ Sounds like a Missy Elliot song. :laughing:

nope. in fact, here in my hometown, there are a lot of exotic dishes served here.
for instance, fried frogs, the one above which is sauted goats, fertilized duck egg, stewed turtle, siopao made of cat meat and sauted dogs among many others. though the last dish is now extinct because of the current Philippine bill that disallows the cooking of dogs or any domestic pets.

Burning Down 06-13-2011 11:15 AM

She was making a joke FFS.

Sansa Stark 06-13-2011 11:21 AM

Goat cheese is pretty good imo

Paedantic Basterd 06-13-2011 11:42 AM

I've recently heard that (and forgive my complete and utter lack of resources for this information, but it's the idea I wanted to bring up) scientists have been using animal stem cells to grow muscle independent of an animal for use as meat product.

Basically, what's the general feeling about eating grown meat, and is this a foreseeable to combat animal cruelty?

Sansa Stark 06-13-2011 11:51 AM

That's gross tbh, it's still like eating an animal to me. I don't think it'll be much for combatting animal cruelty,that's too much of a giant to conquer, and if I recall correctly, doing that is super expensive.

Paedantic Basterd 06-13-2011 11:54 AM

Obviously it's in early stages, but I wonder, if they become able to mass produce this meat, would it be more or less expensive/efficient than farming these animals?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:09 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.