That's a bit off topic. Vanilla posed a question, people are just giving honest answers.

She's far from ugly, but a tad too big I'd say. Also, all these people have model faces. Your average size 16 person off the street doesn't look nearly as good to be honest. Size 12 looks pretty damn good.

They're all beautiful in their own way.

Honestly the size 16 girl has the prettier face and better body. Great rack and pretty face.

The size 4-8 on the far left is not my style. If she were 5 foot 1, sure, she'd probably be much cuter in my book. But she's too tall to be that skinny. It's almost unhealthy at that point isn't it. I'd rather either of the other two. Yes, that girl that is size 16 in that picture is more attractive than the 4-8 on the opposite side, especially her facial features. But, yeah, if the girl in the middle was into me, I'd have a heart attack and die, because she is too pretty.

What's up with the stances? I don't know what the picture was taken for, but couldn't they have just done it mug-shot style, arms at sides, no raised knees? If they were trying to compare, I'm not sure why they all strike different poses...

The smallest girl's legs are so skinny, it's nasty.

http://backcountrypost.com/forum/add...s/facepalm.gif

> Thread about poor, judgemental attitudes towards women of certain body types, mentioning plus size.

> Proceeds to go too far in the other direction and ends up calling skinny girls "nasty".


This is the problem with these threads.

Not that anyone wants to know but I would ravage all three given the chance.

She's not nasty in general, just her legs are way too skinny. Compared to some of the things said in this thread it really wasn't meant that way. Fact is, she's just as unhealthy as the bigger girl, if not more.

I'm with you all the way. I wouldn't even shower in between.

Number 3 for me all the way. Number 2 is stunning but way out of my league and how often are you going to come across women looking like that who just happen to be down to earth to boot? Number one? I would be scared to jump it in fear of breakages.

As to the OP, if I posted near naked pictures of myself then I would expect all sorts of criticism regardless of body shape or size. You would be surprised as to what MEN are looking for and appreciate but not be surprised that people are giving opinions either whether they are positive, negative or downright ugly.

Is it nice to read negativity? Of course it isn't but this is the digital age and it is commonplace now but it is not a 'snapshot' of what every person thinks regarding body size.

It's easy to be negative in life, it's the positives that one should cling to.