![]() |
bark collars
what is the consensus on bark collars? i know this forum is full of bleeding hearts. though i also know that invisible fences are pretty commonly used by animal lovers. my dogs won't shut the **** up no matter what i try. i am pretty close to strapping them with bark collars at this point. do you guys think this is cruel?
|
If you have to put a bark collar on your dog and you refuse tp train it properly, you shouldn't own a dog.
Speaking in general, not you specifically. |
Quote:
Agree with Ki. But if you decide to go that route anyway..... Bark collars are not all created equal. If you are going to use one be sure to research them. I'd call your local SPCA or vet and ask them what collar they would recommend. Some of them will shock by accident if the collar is bumped or for other reasons. |
I think they're inhumane, because some dogs get traumatized by that shit. Introducing your dog to your smacking hand would be better (I'm okay with that as long as you don't overdo it).
|
well i didn't want to own a dog to be perfectly honest. i got stuck with these dogs through a series of circumstances. i don't know what else to do with them other than bring them to the pound.
but i am open to suggestions on how to get them to stop barking all the time... that's why i made this thread. i don't actually want to put bark collars on them i just don't know how to train dogs and they are honestly driving me crazy. |
Knowing dogs, they probably just want a place to run around. Do you keep your dogs in a small apartment? do you let them out in a yard? Most of the time the barking is due to the dog not getting the attention or exercise that it needs. Its pretty easy to find the source, just gotta make sure your living arrangements are suitable for dogs as well as yourself.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
it seems like the main source of them barking is any time the see a person or another dog outside through the window |
You have any dog parks nearby? That'll allow them to run like crazy and also get more comfortable around other dogs.
|
The barking at other dogs is a territorial thing I think. Especially if its a dog they don't know very well. They're basically telling the other dogs "hey this is my yard, stay away."
Also I agree with Chula. Getting them comfortable with other dogs would help. |
i'm not sure. not that i know of.
|
Quote:
|
honestly it comes across to me like they like other dogs. they just get excited whenever they see one
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
so let me ask a question to you guys just for the sake of argument... are invisible fences inhumane to you too? and if not then why not if bark collars are?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I agree with chula that not all bark collars are the same. There are some I would never use and some that I've tried with my dog that worked temporarily. Training a vocal dog to not bark is not as easy as it's made out to be, so you have my sympathy.
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
No shock collars. No hitting. If you don't want to take the time to understand how the animal you want to own works than you shouldn't get one. (generalized not directed @ ya JWB)
-Reward the dogs when they are not barking, and being calm. |
Quote:
Don't forget too, you want your dog to bark at certain occasions. Most importantly, when there are intruders trying to get into your house, or people you want to scare off (noisy gang that won't move on etc). As well as that, stopping a dog barking is taking its natural instinct away, and although I've never heard of these bark collars (but I now hate them) it soudns like they would do dangerous psychological damage to the dog. What does your vet say? Remember, your dog(s) deserve(s) to be treated fairly too; he/she/they are not just something you push the mute button on when they get too loud. Part of the joy of having a dog is the happy bark; you don't want to take that away. Learn how to control them properly. Ever watch The Dog Whisperer? |
no, can't say i have. honestly though i look forward to the day when i'm not a pet owner. i actually do like animals, truth be told. i just like them best as either wild animals or other people's pets.
don't worry though. for all my apathy / seeming heartlessness, i don't want to do anything cruel. i had a feeling everyone would feel this way. i'm not gonna get the bark collars. if worse comes to worse i will just deal with the fact that they bark. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
I absolutely support the use of bark collars, just not on dogs.
|
what about on children?
|
Babies only.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
that wouldn't work on me when i was a kid. i would just report you to the fbi as a secret muslim
|
Quote:
|
that wouldn't be likely to happen. never used to bark much as a kid.
though i did go through a phase when i was around 5 or so when i thought i was half dinosaur after i saw jurassic park. my parents gave me this one book which was about what it would be like if dinosaurs were still around. it had dinosaurs doing all sorts of work helping humans out. there was one page which had a t-rex helping lumberjacks by biting down trees. anyway, there was this one really young a skinny pine tree in our yard and i was pretty confident i could take it. wound up slinking away in shame with a mouth full of bark and sap. that ended my half-dinosaur phase. |
There are collars that release an unpleasant scent or high pitched sound when the dog barks, and I had one briefly that simply vibrated. There are certainly options.
|
Can you silence a half dinosaur with it though?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
The vibrating totally worked, it had a low and high setting, he would just at get a confused look on his face and eventually stopped barking at all anytime it was on him. I imagine it felt weird but it certainly wasn't painful for him. I would have kept using it but I left it within his reach and te ****er ate it. |
Don't hit your dog JWB.
|
i don't, i was just asking. honestly all i ever do is yell at them. doesn't really work though.
|
Did you even watch the videos I posted?
|
no. i will though. i'm not gonna be doing any dog training right now so it seems pointless to watch them until i need them
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:54 PM. |
© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.