Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   The Relationship Thread (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/95137-relationship-thread.html)

OccultHawk 11-23-2020 09:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 2146047)
Penises exist because women selected for them.

Can confirm

OccultHawk 11-23-2020 09:48 PM

Is it caused by a supernatural force then?

OccultHawk 11-23-2020 09:58 PM

Quote:

social influences
This is supernatural?

The Batlord 11-23-2020 10:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2146066)
if the question is whether men are more violent naturally that enters the realm of super controversial

I mean men simply are more violent than women and we have a culture of violence. And if male violence doesn't affect women in a way that reduces reproduction then it's possible that evolution is essentially thowing women under the bus and allowing them to be brutalized so that male violence can be maintained as a desirable trait.

Lucem Ferre 11-23-2020 10:12 PM

I know one thing. You guys surely haven't evolved to shut the **** up.

jwb 11-23-2020 10:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2146063)
nah this is pretty controversial

I guess it depends on how you look at it

beating your wife, the gather part of your hunter gather tribe, is not a beneficial trait...

is it a byproduct? maybe, but it seems to me actually to be a largely separate phenomenon that does follow from a historical influence

when you get into specific forms of violence obviously the cultural influence increases

But the propensity for violence in general is higher in men than in women. It seems like it would be a rather strange coincidence that the stronger sex that did most of the hunting and fighting is also more violent. I would say it's more of a stretch that this is not related to our evolution than to presume that it probably is.

jwb 11-23-2020 10:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2146070)
social influences

+ men are just bigger

could be biological too, but if you search it you'll see that nobody agrees on this

why are men bigger?

OccultHawk 11-23-2020 10:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2146078)
why are men bigger?

The culture ghost.

jwb 11-23-2020 10:58 PM

It's always possible

It's also possible that the violence in men is rooted in biology and the culture of violence is something that manifested as a result in order to reinforce this existing dynamic

Since it seems pretty ubiquitous across cultures and has clear physiological indicators (as you said, men are bigger) and also conveniently aligns with the primitive division of labor (men as hunters and warriors)... It seems like there's a good chance this isn't all some big coincidence

This is what I was saying about terms like social construct and conditioning not being mutually exclusive with biological answers. Technically, "species" is a social construct. So is "life." Neither of these categories have straight forward definitions that apply across the board, the same way genders and sex don't. That doesn't mean they aren't essentially describing an underlying biological reality.

jwb 11-23-2020 11:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2146084)
Yeah but in modern day rich societies senseless violence is exceedingly rare

you have domestic violence and gang related violence accounting for the incredible majority

so it seems like we'd want to look at the causes there, rather than suppose some natural violence thing in the male brain (these assumptions almost always turn out wrong)

they're more rare yes. That doesn't detract from the fact that men are much more prone towards violence even in these richer societies. That's true regardless of how advanced or primitive a society is.

That's not to say I'm saying the answers to how to decrease violence aren't going to be sociological as opposed to biological. Obviously that's true. But the inherent propensity difference is probably something with a biological component to it.

It's like racism. Racism is clearly a sort of modern manifestation of tribalism, which is somewhat natural. But the way to address racism is socially. There are no biological remedies for it.

The Batlord 11-23-2020 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2146084)
Yeah but in modern day rich societies senseless violence is exceedingly rare

you have domestic violence and gang related violence accounting for the incredible majority

so it seems like we'd want to look at the causes there, rather than suppose some natural violence thing in the male brain (these assumptions almost always turn out wrong)

Translation: rednecks and black people are violent but I'm cool.

jwb 11-23-2020 11:23 PM

Just as many if not more assumptions that have come out of psychology and sociology have been wrong

The idea that biology applies to every organism except humans is just our own hubris

jwb 11-23-2020 11:39 PM

Not really

It's an advantage that we can learn behavior and pass on information verbally

That doesn't mean we ceased to have instincts or became less reliant on them

Rather our instincts expanded to include the ability to learn things via social interaction and observation. All of this serves the same basic function that any instinct serves. Which is just guidelines to live by.

jwb 11-23-2020 11:56 PM

Source?

I mean you are straight up delusional if you think nature somehow doesn't apply to us cause through some natural process we superceded nature.

jwb 11-24-2020 12:10 AM

That's sorta my point though

Societal influences are informed to a large extent by natural trends

So proclaiming it's social and not natural is just as nonsensical as claiming the reverse.

jwb 11-24-2020 12:13 AM

So take a drug that affects you physiologically to erase the influence of nature

Makes sense

jwb 11-24-2020 12:18 AM

You could say the same about biology lol.

The social aspect is just an extension of biology in reality.

OccultHawk 11-24-2020 12:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2146142)
You could say the same about biology lol.

The social aspect is just an extension of biology in reality.

The ghost extension

jwb 11-24-2020 12:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2146141)
it's to erase social influence or probably deconstruct it

as the postmodernists started to point out the degree that language has an influence on our thinking

what makes you think taking drugs removes social influence?

It's funny how you are proposing all this stuff and yet are skeptical about the most basic and mainstream biology.

jwb 11-24-2020 12:33 AM

I understand the difference

You're just wrong in assuming that one overrides the other completely

You didn't even know what sexual selection was at the start of this convo so don't even bother trying to act like you're on sone different level of understanding. Both me and OH understand this question better than you do.

Frownland 11-24-2020 12:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2146079)
The culture ghost.

I know you're being facetious, but anachronisms that maintain credibility via regression to the mean and are perpetuated by social cues are tantamount to being possessed by the dead, aka ghosts.

jwb 11-24-2020 12:44 AM

Lol what?

Give me a serious scientific link that says sexual selection is controversial.

jwb 11-24-2020 12:50 AM

And it is about overrides. You just said a few posts ago that our biology lead to us being so completely ruled by learned behavior that you would "win a noble prize" if you could show a way in which we are bound in any way to nature.

OccultHawk 11-24-2020 12:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frownland (Post 2146162)
I know you're being facetious, but anachronisms that maintain credibility via regression to the mean and are perpetuated by social cues are tantamount to being possessed by the dead, aka ghosts.

This is how it’s done people

jwb 11-24-2020 01:01 AM

I can't read the paper, just the abstract, but it does not at all call sexual selection as a concept into question. In fact, the abstract ends as such:

Quote:

Recent studies show that both intrasexual competition between females and male choice of mating partners are common, leading to strong sexual selection in females and, in extreme cases, to reversals in the usual pattern of sex differences in behavior and morphology.
Dunno why you would possibly think this is calling sexual selection into question lol

The Batlord 11-24-2020 01:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2146174)
I could give you them however they're massive abstracts that I just Google'd

Actual lol

The Batlord 11-24-2020 01:04 AM

Special ed mother****er.

jwb 11-24-2020 01:06 AM

Honestly sexual selection is just as grounded in biology as natural selection

You might as well start repping intelligent design

Lucem Ferre 11-24-2020 01:38 AM

citation needed

WWWP 11-24-2020 07:53 PM

Non-evolutionary themed relationship question-

How much, if at all, do you judge a romantic interest for their exes?

OccultHawk 11-24-2020 07:57 PM

No judgment from me. People change their minds. Get horny. Get sad. Get lonely. Get nostalgic. And just miss someone. Happens all the time. It’s a good reason to break up amicably.

OccultHawk 11-24-2020 08:30 PM

Oh if they have a lot of **** exes.

Don’t care.

WWWP 11-24-2020 08:39 PM

This girl I've been seeing was in a similar situation to me when we met - we had both ended long-term relationships at the beginning of quarantine and decided to continue living with our exes through the end of the year for the benefit of all involved. Naturally the subject of our exes comes up a lot, and jesus christ I know my relationship was ****ed up in a lot of ways, but ffs hers stresses me out to even imagine. The things she put up with and participated in are making me start to think of her differently. Logically I know that's not fair, and I know that I will never understand the full scope of their dynamic, and so it's fruitless to even analyze. But like it's a little concerning that her standards are so low. I think ultimately it all comes back to my own insecurities, like "how could she want a relationship with THAT but not want a relationship with me?" [I'm actively avoiding monogamy but it's like some lizard brain ****]

OccultHawk 11-24-2020 08:43 PM

Exes are the worst subject ever. Don’t ask. Don’t tell.

WWWP 11-24-2020 10:07 PM

Well I ignored your advice and talked to her about it. Through communication we cleared everything up and all is well.

The Batlord 11-24-2020 10:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WWWP (Post 2146452)
This girl I've been seeing was in a similar situation to me when we met - we had both ended long-term relationships at the beginning of quarantine and decided to continue living with our exes through the end of the year for the benefit of all involved. Naturally the subject of our exes comes up a lot, and jesus christ I know my relationship was ****ed up in a lot of ways, but ffs hers stresses me out to even imagine. The things she put up with and participated in are making me start to think of her differently. Logically I know that's not fair, and I know that I will never understand the full scope of their dynamic, and so it's fruitless to even analyze. But like it's a little concerning that her standards are so low. I think ultimately it all comes back to my own insecurities, like "how could she want a relationship with THAT but not want a relationship with me?" [I'm actively avoiding monogamy but it's like some lizard brain ****]

I don't know her or her situation obviously so this just a ball I'm tossing in the air but the way you described her made her sound manipulative so you never know how honest she was being. It can be real easy to lie to a stranger to make yourself look sympathetic.

goldendoodle 11-24-2020 10:30 PM

I'm always a bit wary of those who right off the bat demonize ALL their exes, call ALL of them "crazy" etc. (..Or any of them, for that matter, unless obviously there's clearly a good reason for it.) Oftentimes they are in fact the crazy ones, and psychologically torture and gaslight everyone they date until they nearly are crazy.

But then there are those who habitually get sucked into the orbit of destructive people genuinely without consciously meaning to; in some cases this is clearly due to an abusive upbringing coupled with a lack of self-esteem. Manipulative/abusive/narcissistic types can sniff out that specific type of vulnerable person from MILES away.

Soo I try not to immediately judge a person for their exes. Not until I learn more about it (even though obviously you're only getting one perspective, unless you stalk the other one online a little to find their side of the story, which I've done before) and see if there's a distinct pattern in their relationships or not (their endings and beginnings etc).

I see no problem with discussing exes or just past relationships in general. It's usually enlightening. obviously it's something that is bound to come up when having an honest discussion about one's past mistakes or psychological issues.

OccultHawk 11-24-2020 10:55 PM

Ain’t nobody you’re ****ing wants to hear you talking about who you was ****ing. Ain’t nothin good coming out of that conversation.

jwb 11-24-2020 11:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WWWP (Post 2146452)
This girl I've been seeing was in a similar situation to me when we met - we had both ended long-term relationships at the beginning of quarantine and decided to continue living with our exes through the end of the year for the benefit of all involved. Naturally the subject of our exes comes up a lot, and jesus christ I know my relationship was ****ed up in a lot of ways, but ffs hers stresses me out to even imagine. The things she put up with and participated in are making me start to think of her differently. Logically I know that's not fair, and I know that I will never understand the full scope of their dynamic, and so it's fruitless to even analyze. But like it's a little concerning that her standards are so low. I think ultimately it all comes back to my own insecurities, like "how could she want a relationship with THAT but not want a relationship with me?" [I'm actively avoiding monogamy but it's like some lizard brain ****]

didn't you suggest she was still in love with the ex or something

Tbh I smell trouble there but that's just me

That's why I hate monogamy. If you stop caring who else your partner ****s with then you can view it as either they choose to keep seeing you or they don't. Then you truly don't have to worry about the ex at all.

The last sentence in your post says it all. You are looking for validation through your partner. That's monogamy 101 bruh.

goldendoodle 11-24-2020 11:08 PM

@Hawk: Sure, if you view it that way. It's not about discussing the PERSON so much as, like, pointing out relationships that contributed to some current neurotic habit/fear or paranoia/whatever you may deal with. (Like for instance I still get SUPER NERVOUS and fearful when a very loud rowdy drunk near me is binge drinking beer or something, because both the smell and the sound of the person crashing around viscerally brings up memories of an alcoholic ex I had who became somewhat physically aggressive when with me in private while drunk. So I've had to explain that before after being asked why I suddenly froze and disassociated when the aforementioned type of person entered a small bar we were in)
It's completely reasonable.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:08 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.