Green Day - 21st Century Breakdown

[justinlove05]

Where did they go wrong. Dookie was by far their best album

[Antonio]

i'm more partial to Nimrod myself, but everyone's got their opinion i guess

Originally Posted by AwwSugar

You know, a lot of hardcore GD fans hate Warning.



Just saying.

i love Warning, a real stripped down sound in their musical evolution. my least favorites are Kerplunk and Insomniac, they just seemed to lack an overall direction and it seems that some songs are just there as filler. not saying they're all bad though, there's really good stuff in all of their albums.

[Arya Stark]

You think so?

I didn't start liking them until American Idiot.

Isn't that weird?

[Antonio]

nah, i'm pretty certain different people gravitate towards different eras of their music. plus it's a real change in their sound, so it's normal some new fans'd be made who would gravitate to that and not so much the stuff beforehand, as well as fans of Dookie who aren't too partial to the earlier stuff.

also, i just wanna respond to this post:

Originally Posted by AwwSugar

What do you mean by that? You think they didn't try to make a good album?

not saying that they didn't try; i know they did. just that not all of the pieces fell into the right place for this one if you catch my drift. like some oppurtunities in songs to say, add a new melody/speed up the music/slow down the music or do something different were passed up.


then again, this is my point of view.

[Arya Stark]

You're really late answering all of this. xD

[Antonio]

yeah, but it's late over here and i just woke up.

[Arya Stark]

No I mean, I said all of that a long time ago. Hahaha.

[Antonio]

yeah, wanted to tie up some loose ends

[Arya Stark]

Haha, it happens.

Are they making the musical out of this album or American Idiot?

I forgot.

[Antonio]

i think it's American Idiot, but i could be mistaken.