The Beatles vs The Beach Boys - Music Banter Music Banter

Go Back   Music Banter > The Music Forums > Pop
Register Blogging Today's Posts
Welcome to Music Banter Forum! Make sure to register - it's free and very quick! You have to register before you can post and participate in our discussions with over 70,000 other registered members. After you create your free account, you will be able to customize many options, you will have the full access to over 1,100,000 posts.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 02-27-2013, 02:02 PM   #1 (permalink)
carpe musicam
 
Neapolitan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Les Barricades Mystérieuses
Posts: 7,710
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cinnamonics View Post
Ok, you're going into lala-land by now. George Martin did not "make" their first big hit "Please Please Me", recording aside. He disliked the initial arrangement and suggested the boys speed it up, but the rest was up the Beatles themselves, and they radically altered it to the point where it was believed it could be a hit. As for "A Day in the Life", yes that was two seperate songs initially. I don't how good Paul's part could've been on its own, but in my mind John's part would've been great in any case, though together they become something special. Anyway, it was McCartney's idea to join the two pieces via an orchestra. George Martin supported that idea by writing a loose score, but it was not his idea. In general, George Martin was known to suggest a thing here or there, and implement small pieces of music, but to say he was the pop genius behind The Beatles' success is ridiculous. As a producer he was very, very important, but NOT as a writer, c'mon. Your whole attitude towards the band is very telling with your inclusion of "knifing Pete Best in the back", so I shouldn't really take your post seriously, but dammit, good band on good forum needs some defending from silly people. :p
A Day in the Life is like a precursor to the Medley on Abbey Road, which in turn is a precursor to what Prog did, piece together small pieces of music into one long song.

The main problem about Please Please Me for George Martin was that it was "rather dreary" it was slow pace like a Roy Obison song, and they sped up the tempo.

Quote:
Originally Posted by John Lennon
"I remember the day I wrote it, I heard Roy Orbison doing "Only the Lonely", or something. And I was also always intrigued by the words to a Bing Crosby song that went, 'Please lend a little ear to my pleas'. The double use of the word 'please'. So it was a combination of Roy Orbison and Bing Crosby". -The Beatles 2000, p. 90.
PLEASE ~ Bing Crosby 1932
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by mord View Post
Actually, I like you a lot, Nea. That's why I treat you like ****. It's the MB way.

"it counts in our hearts" ?ºº?
“I have nothing to offer anybody, except my own confusion.” Jack Kerouac.
“If one listens to the wrong kind of music, he will become the wrong kind of person.” Aristotle.
"If you tried to give Rock and Roll another name, you might call it 'Chuck Berry'." John Lennon
"I look for ambiguity when I'm writing because life is ambiguous." Keith Richards
Neapolitan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-09-2010, 09:20 AM   #2 (permalink)
James
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Abstain I love them both but if The Beach Boys had quit 10 years earlier they would win.
  Reply With Quote
Old 05-09-2010, 10:00 AM   #3 (permalink)
The Music Guru.
 
Burning Down's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Beyond the Wall
Posts: 4,858
Default

Both are great and both bands had unique talents that worked for them. The Beach Boys had the ability to harmonize beautifully while the Beatles wrote complex instrumental parts. The Beatles always had more intricate bass lines, as Paul McCartney was (and still is) more competent than Brian Wilson was on the bass guitar. Also, the early music of both bands grew out of two completely different genres. The Beach Boys were more influenced by California surf music of the late 50's/early 60's, while the Beatles were heavily influenced by the DIY skiffle music that was popular among the working class people in England.
Burning Down is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-10-2010, 01:25 PM   #4 (permalink)
Divination
 
Necromancer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 2,655
Default Reviews. Beatles & Beach Boys

Quote:
Originally Posted by Burning Down View Post
Both are great and both bands had unique talents that worked for them. The Beach Boys had the ability to harmonize beautifully while the Beatles wrote complex instrumental parts. The Beatles always had more intricate bass lines, as Paul McCartney was (and still is) more competent than Brian Wilson was on the bass guitar. Also, the early music of both bands grew out of two completely different genres. The Beach Boys were more influenced by California surf music of the late 50's/early 60's, while the Beatles were heavily influenced by the DIY skiffle music that was popular among the working class people in England.
I like your short review on the subject, I dont know if I agree that McCartney is all that more competent on bass guitar than Wilson was, I always thought McCartney was a little overrated as an accomplished bass player in my book when holding in consideration to the level of talented bassist from that era, Although..I will admit that I may be a little bias with my opinion, since I almost always support the 'underdog'. I have a friend from Iowa that thinks George Harrison is it! when it comes to guitarist, and I really respect this guys opinion, hell he is an unknown muti talented artist in his own right, the only point I am trying to suggest is, I just dont believe that the Beatles were all that much more talented as musicians, when compared to the musical talent of the Beach Boys, I will conclude that the Beatles had Mccartney & Lennon both on the same team which is the only real advantage the Beatles did have over the BBs. I would have to hear more detailed facts about the music & history of these two bands before I could state an honest opinion myself. Realisticly...I would not be surprised if the Beatles are the most talented, Its just something I will have to find out for myself when the time permits itself for me to be able to review the subject. Whos albums are listend to the most by the masses, who gets the most airtime & play, I suggest a 'Tie' between both bands, The Beatles cant win by Hands Down, or by the phrase- "I cant believe its even a question in your mind" -statement, What are some of the statictics, facts and of course personal opinions as always, All is open for debate

Last edited by Necromancer; 05-10-2010 at 11:17 PM. Reason: I JUST FUNKING WANTED TO!
Necromancer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-29-2010, 12:44 PM   #5 (permalink)
telepicker
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Burning Down View Post
Pet Sounds WAS much better than Sgt. Pepper's in terms of fluidity. I love the Beatles, but Sgt. Pepper's is definitely a weaker album in their discography. I don't know why, I guess that's just how I feel about it.
well, the discussion wasn't "Pet Sounds" vs. "Sgt. Pepper." - it's Beatles vs. Beach Boys.

And "Sgt. Pepper" may be the worst LP in the Beatles catalog.



Quote:
Originally Posted by cactus waltz View Post
That's a bit of an unfair argument, as it says more about the stability of Brian Wilson's psyche than it does of his capability as a musician. We know that he was depressed and had a troubled childhood, but that he was a great talent nonetheless..
maybe unfair...but entirely accurate.

I don't care about his depression; my dad beat me when I was a kid, too - I don't get to have a breakdown and lay in bed for years because of it.

Lennon was abandoned by both parents; his mom died when he was just starting to reconnect with her...but he wrote top-notch stuff his entire life.

Quote:
Originally Posted by cactus waltz View Post

For me personally, the Beach Boys have slightly more high emotional peaks than the Beatles. "Pet Sounds" is my favorite album of all time, after all. I also think that if Brian Wilson hadn't collapsed and had been able to release "Smile" as was intended (discounting the 2004 version), it would've been a classic on par with Sergeant Pepper and it'll always be a bit of a thorn in my side that things went the way they did. Songs like "Heroes ans villains", "Good vibrations" and especially "Surf's up" are simply brilliant, multi-layered and splendid..
I agree - Pet Sounds is a masterful record.

Smile could have been great.



Quote:
Originally Posted by cactus waltz View Post
But yeah. It's difficult. Maybe I have to give it to the Beatles in the end, for all of their accomplishments and rock history "firsts". That was an awful lot of pioneering in a few years. They were also hugely talented and all-rounded and had a number of great songs and albums. Comparing the two, I think my "objective" vote goes to the Beatles, but the Beach Boys are closer to my heart.
I guess I can understand that - basically, you're saying that our personal preference is the Beach Boys, but that the Beatles are obviously more consistant.

Yeah, I agree somewhat - the Beach Boys' high points eere arguably as good or better than the Beatles from '63-'66...but from '67-on, the Beatles surpassed the Beach Boys by far.

The sheer consistancy of the Beatles recorded catalog (every song from every album is a winner) compared to the Beach Boys (some really good songs mixed with an overwhelming amount of schlocky crap) would easily beat that out.

Great first post.


Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
I like your short review on the subject, I dont know if I agree that McCartney is all that more competent on bass guitar than Wilson was, I always thought McCartney was a little overrated as an accomplished bass player in my book when holding in consideration to the level of talented bassist from that era,
umm...have you ever heard "Drive My Car"?

"Taxman"?

"I'm Only Sleeping"?

How 'bout "I Want You (She's So Heavy)"?

Or "Come Together"?

"While My Guitar Gently Weeps"?

Paul had a knack for coming up with inventive, moving grooving basslines which were complex but not obtrusive; moving but rock solid; simple but harmonically complex, all at the same time.

I would rather listen to Paul dong descending runs in "Why Dont We do It in the Road" than anything Victor Wooten has ever done.

As much respect I have for players like Wooten, Flea, or Claypool...my favorite bassists are guys like McCartney, Rick Danko, Geezer Butler, Sven Pipien, Duff McKagan,John McVie, Carl Radle, Nikki Sixx, etc. Guys who work with their drummer and bandmates as a rhythm section. I LOVE Ronnie Wood's bass playing on those first Jeff Beck records. Two recent favorites are Tod Bowers from the Steepwater Band and Shonna Tucker from Drive-By Truckers.

You know; dudes who play the SONG, who don't care about showing off as much as making the SONG sound as good as possible.

Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
Although..I will admit that I may be a little bias with my opinion, since I almost always support the 'underdog'. I have a friend from Iowa that thinks George Harrison is it!
when it comes to guitarist, and I really respect this guys opinion,
George Harrison IS "it as a guitarist" - so, this makes you biased against Paul as a bassist?

Because your friend in Iowa thinks George is awesome?


Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
hell he is an unknown muti talented artist in his own right,
aren't we all?

Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
the only point I am trying to suggest is, I just dont believe that the Beatles were all that much more talented as musicians,
really?

Is that why they played all the intruments on all their records, and the Beach Boys ALWAYS used LA session musicians on their records?

Can you explain this situation to me?

Was it that the Beach Boys were so damn good that they didn't NEED to play?

Them Beatles, all show-offy...making their records sound good by playing their own instruments just 'cause they can or sumpin'...

Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
when compared to the musical talent of the Beach Boys, I will conclude that the Beatles had Mccartney & Lennon both on the same team which is the only real advantage the Beatles did have over the BBs.
what about George?

I thought you really respected your friend in Iowa's opinion?

I figured that a world-class lead guitarist would be a "real advantage"? Not to mention the fact that George wrote some really awesome songs in his own right.

Also, I would think having a drummer that could actually play and keep time (Ringo) would be better than having the musical liability that was Dennis Wilson.

The Beatles also had the advantage of having better SOUNDING records, fidelity-wise. Compare, say, "Fun, Fun, Fun" to "I Saw Her Standing There" - the Beatles song has a bigger, more full sound, as well as having better definition as far instrument fidelity.

The Beatles had George Martin, Geoff Emerick, and Abbey Road - which made their records simply sound better (another reason why the Beatles were the better band - they didn't have their dad's megalomanically running the control room, ruining their records like Murray Wilson did the Beach Boys'.)


Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
I would have to hear more detailed facts about the music & history of these two bands before I could state an honest opinion myself.
looks like it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
Realisticly...I would not be surprised if the Beatles are the most talented, Its just something I will have to find out for myself when the time permits itself for me to be able to review the subject.
you shouldn't be surprised...and that new Mono boxset of Beatles is well worth the investment

Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post

Whos albums are listend to the most by the masses, who gets the most airtime & play,
the Beatles sell more, are played more, and more revered around the world.

Quote:
Originally Posted by VocalsBass View Post
I suggest a 'Tie' between both bands, The Beatles cant win by Hands Down, or by the phrase- "I cant believe its even a question in your mind" -statement, What are some of the statictics, facts and of course personal opinions as always, All is open for debate
well, I can't believe it IS a question - the Beatles are realistically superior in almost every single category, especially the most important one: who played together the bes. - as a BAND?

It most certainly was not the dudes who took good pictures and had the best LA session musicians playing in their recird's that they hired outside writers to write the lyrics for.
  Reply With Quote
Old 06-29-2010, 01:04 PM   #6 (permalink)
Mate, Spawn & Die
 
Janszoon's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: The Rapping Community
Posts: 24,593
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by telepicker View Post
The sheer consistancy of the Beatles recorded catalog (every song from every album is a winner) compared to the Beach Boys (some really good songs mixed with an overwhelming amount of schlocky crap) would easily beat that out.
No. Just no.
Janszoon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-02-2010, 12:37 AM   #7 (permalink)
Divination
 
Necromancer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 2,655
Wink Brian Wilson

I find comparing the close relationship that the Beatles and the Beach Boys shared between each other from that certain era of 1961 and on, the be the most interesting view for me, instead of reflecting on the subject of who is the best of the two bands mentioned.
But I have to admit that I find Brian Wilson to be a unique, interesting, and intriguing legacy to review personally, (in conclusion) if the term musical genius is to be applied, then Brian Wilson should surely qualify for that position.
I mean Wilson was noticed for his natural musical abilities at the early age of two and three years old, at the age of eight he was backed by a church choir.
Its interesting the way he introduced 'doubletracking' into production at that certain time in 1963, and how he was also influenced by Phil Spector for one to mention, Wilson was known to strive for perfection in the studio.
And to the fact that the Beatles suggested Wilson was a major influence to their music.
And I was really shocked when I found that it affected Wilsons mental stabililty when Paul McCartney played a tape of 'A Day In The Life' for Wilson off of the Beatles Peppers album in Los Angeles, 1966.
Theres just so much interesting info. to review concerning the Beach Boys albums, production, personal life, you just have to get the whole story for yourself.
I might mention Brian Wilson does have an album release scheduled for Aug. 17th, 2010.
'Brian Wilsons Reimagines Gershwin', which includes Wilson completing two unfinished pieces by Gershwin, its hard to believe this guy is still making deals and recording (Disney Pearl Label).
Necromancer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-04-2010, 10:48 PM   #8 (permalink)
Groupie
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 4
Cool The Beatles.

Yup.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Burning Down View Post
Both are great and both bands had unique talents that worked for them. The Beach Boys had the ability to harmonize beautifully while the Beatles wrote complex instrumental parts. The Beatles always had more intricate bass lines, as Paul McCartney was (and still is) more competent than Brian Wilson was on the bass guitar. Also, the early music of both bands grew out of two completely different genres. The Beach Boys were more influenced by California surf music of the late 50's/early 60's, while the Beatles were heavily influenced by the DIY skiffle music that was popular among the working class people in England.
1jared1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-10-2010, 09:21 PM   #9 (permalink)
Groupie
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 20
Default

The Beatles > The Beach Boys
stemart316 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 05-10-2010, 09:41 PM   #10 (permalink)
Mate, Spawn & Die
 
Janszoon's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: The Rapping Community
Posts: 24,593
Default

Beach Boys, easily. Simply better pop songs and the only band of the two with an album that I can actually enjoy from beginning to end.
Janszoon is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Similar Threads



© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.