**** all of u that have responded to this thread. I dought any of u low-life pieces of **** ****ing ****-****s actually play instruments. U all probably live in ur parents basements. A real musician would respect what greenday has done for music. One more thing Dont be giving me this **** about blink-182 Greenday has been around along time before them and sound a whole lot more punk.

:finger: :finger:

OK, dude.... first off- I do play instruments like...like 5 of them... So dont tell me im not an active musican....second- I listen to some of GD's older stuff...Im listening to them right now on FUSE... and third....Im 14...Of course I live in my parents house...what? do you want me to go out and try to find some place to live?? im pretty sure they dont let 14-year-olds live by themselvs... Dont get me wrong... like GD is pretty cool....but punk is more like... Rancid or The Ramones... GD is like....alternitive Im not tryin to start **** with you...im simply speaking my mind.

ha ha...i dont live in my parents basement...i live at a college campus where I am educated...obviously unlike yourself....'dought' wtf is that dude? and btw i was kidding about the whole blink 182 thing....but i am serious when i say good charlotte is punk...or at least more punk than greenday

why would a serious musician have respect for greenday? nothing they do is exceptional, nor technically difficult. could you elaborate on exactly what they have done for music? as i, and im sure many others, are not following you when you say that.

i play seven insturments



good charlotte is also pop/rock, not trying to piss people off here, but this forum is really getting on my nerves.....

GreenDay... I like them. Basket Case is a damn good song. And their American Idiot album rocks!

Greenday formed in 1990 but didn't put out there first album until late 1991
Blink 182 formed in the spring of 1992 and recorded their first EP 4 months later

They are not far off. And what has Greenday done for punk music? And I'm 15 and do live at home. Whoop dee do. Go listen to your happy punk.

And I play the guitar, piano, and bass guitar (not well though, I'm still learning)

yeah, I really like Greenday But dude, i hate to break it to you they are not punk. They are not pop punk either! They are alternative! :wavey:

i like their old stuff. Their new stuff seems...different : \ but im still a fan

and since i have to pick my favorite song... id have to pick, cast away.

I dont much care for green day. I like some of there stuff, but there not to great. I admit they've inspired alot of bands, but unfoirtunetly I think at least half the bands they inspired are total garbage too. Whatever, to each his own.

cast away is an awesome song too.

you know how much homework i had last week.

my favorite song by them is definatly the grouch. its just so funny.

good charlotte is just as ****ty of a band as ****in Simple Plan

I like "Hitchin' a Ride"...^^
but I really didn't listen to all of their songs...
so I'll see what you guys like and listen to it...^^

the sons on nimrad i think are the best ones

you need to get over the your strict guidelines of genre...

Everyone knows that Green Day are not punk! Some of their songs are sort of Punky - American Idiot for a start. It takes the piss out of old Dubya. And minority to some extent as well. Green Day are still one of the best bands for our generation in the world at the moment.

"Green Day are still one of the best bands for our generation in the world at the moment"


Totaly totaly severely innacurate and untrue.

Piss off

Riteo Green day arent pop punk they r punk!!! & they rwl & stop slaggin each otha off we all got opinons!!!! ya woudnt say green day r pop punk cuz den wot r simple plan thier not pop & deffo not punk!

Greenday are touring in the UK next year, $40 a ticket.

That's not punk.

you people need to figure out what the hell genres are before coming into threads like these. Like I said, not trying to piss people off, but it pisses ME off that everyone is calling all this crap like greenday and simple plan and good charlotte "rEaL puNk muSiC1!" when...its not. punk music means a ****load to me and i hate it when people are all like 'DO U LIEK BLINK182?!11'.

Yeah, Nimrod's an awesome CD.

Nice spelling by the way. :D

yep

Greenday rock out! I loooove dookie

I personally think Warning is their best album. But yeah, Dookie rocks! I really wanna buy it! (Even tho I know all of the songs)...

American Idiot, good riddance, basket case, theyre all ready good, i love their album dookie too.

warning live without warning lol.

Green Day rocks! dookie was a great album but the new
one(American idiot) has a much more edge to it that i like! :beer:

can i get another amen? AMEN

best ****in band to grace the earth in my opinion, their music has enriched my life incredibly.

I'm really liking your name! I can't get enough of this album, its so class - i know it off by heart now! Did anyone read the article about them in Q Magazine this month?

Not my cup of tea!!

nice name! jesus of suburbia is an awesome song.

holy ****! why are u so ************ing obsessed with what genre something is.
get a life.
:drummer:

you really need to LEARN TO READ
i just said why i don't like how people are calling this stuff 100% puNk!1!
BECAUSE ITS NOT.

Does it really matter that they're not 100% punk; they're still f**king class!

jesus u might as well shove it all up ur mother-****ING **** FILLED ASS u dumb bastard!
:finger:

nobody cares about ur stupid little winey posts about putting each band to each genre. Ur a stupid opinionated bastard who sucks his on **** cuz he cant get any.

i don't have a ****,

and you're the one who can't handle the fact that your beloved greenday just isn't punk. stop whining, stop letting my opinions bug you so much if you REALLY don't care what i think