Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Punk (https://www.musicbanter.com/punk/)
-   -   The Fall (https://www.musicbanter.com/punk/13198-fall.html)

squonk 04-26-2011 11:33 AM

i BOUGHT THE LP TOTALE'S TURNS AGED 17 WHEN IT CAME OUT AND NEVER LOOK BACK. NOW I'M A FULLY-FLEDGED MEMBER @THEFALLONLINE AND THIS IS WHAT FALL I HAVE ON MY HARD DISK:

50,000 Fall Fans Can't Be Wrong
458489 A-SIDES
A Part Of America Therein
A Past Gone Mad
Early Fall 1977-1979
Grotesque
Hex Enduction Hour
Middle Class Revolt
Singles, Live and Rarities
Slates EP
The Complete Peel Sessions
The Unutterable
This Nation's Saving Grace


Ol’ Qwerty Bastard 07-28-2018 06:18 AM

what is the usual power ranking of albums by fans of the band?

i was kinda partial to hex edunuction hour but now im kinda thinkin nation's saving grace and live at the witch trials are like hella superior

someone educate me

Goofle 07-28-2018 06:53 AM

The Complete Peel Sessions

Ol’ Qwerty Bastard 07-28-2018 08:21 AM

grotesque is pretty dope, admittedly ive heard it a lot less than the other albums i mentioned.

gonna have to get back to you on the rest.

Goofle 07-28-2018 09:51 AM

Literally only listen to the Peel Sessions.



I mean I may as well post this for the 500th time.

Ol’ Qwerty Bastard 07-28-2018 10:08 AM

aright alright i trust you

gonna check it now

GunmouthGrace 07-30-2018 09:50 PM

.

Frownland 07-30-2018 10:23 PM


GunmouthGrace 07-30-2018 10:44 PM

.

Frownland 07-30-2018 10:50 PM

Heh, didn't see your request. I was just in the mood to listen to that and posted it here because elph bumped. Not a bad starting point though.

GunmouthGrace 07-30-2018 10:56 PM

.

SGR 09-17-2018 11:55 AM

Here's the best Fall song of the last 5 years of their existence.



And here's one of their most overlooked tracks - for my money, a beautiful song.



And their most criminally underrated album - Levitate - comes one of their all time strongest tracks, "Ol' Gang". Just don't think the world was ready for this album - the song is like a periscope view into madness and a band quickly disintegrating:


SGR 07-16-2020 08:41 AM

Bumpin this

'Bend Sinister' is my favorite Fall album - it's got a sense of tension and suspense that none of their other albums have. Granted, it doesn't have the anger and bile that is a dominant trait of many of their other albums, but it hangs together as an album incredibly well. My only disappointment with the album is that 'Auto Tech Pilot' was left off of the original release. It's the perfect closing track for the album.

Their worst album? Tough call, but I've never had much love for 'Are You Are Missing Winner'. Unlike some people, I'm quite fond of most of their '90s releases.

SGR 07-17-2020 11:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2126686)
I like Bend Sinister a lot, but the slower songs are not really The Fall at their strongest imo

Generally elph, I'd agree with you. But honestly when I think about it, my two favorite Fall songs are both slower numbers ("Gross Chapel - British Grenadiers" and "Hexen Def. Strife Knot"). The tendency is that most Fall songs are not slow so in totality, they definitely have a lot more quality fast songs.

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2126686)
they sound like lesser Joy Division rather than their idiosyncratic rockabilly garage punk meets angry dissertation

I'm guessing you're not a big fan of their '90s stuff (Code Selfish, Shiftwork, Middle Class Revolt, etc.)? I think your description fits most of their late-70s to mid-80s output well, but their sound evolved a lot over the years. I can see kinda where you're going with the Joy Division comparison in regards to Bend Sinister, but even then, there were songs on there like Dr. Faustus, Shoulder Pads, Bournemouth Runner, and Mr. Pharmacist that would never appear on a Joy Divison LP (they're not bleak enough - way too peppy).

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2126686)
don't sleep on Are You Missing Winner either

Oh trust me, I've listened quite a few times and I'm not sleeping on it. But your comment did give me pause and I'd like to retract my assertion that I think it's their worst album. I'd actually have to give that honor to Reformation Post TLC. An album with a few gems but also jam-packed with half-baked ideas. AYAMW would probably be my runner-up for worst album (it would rank higher without Afro-Ibis Man) and Cerebral Caustic would probably be the third worst.

SGR 07-19-2020 10:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2126802)
I like some of their 90s albums to a fair degree, just not as much as their early stuff ofc

they get better in the 00s (like everything did)

Out of curiosity, what is your favorite '90s Fall album? (I promise, you tell me yours, and I'll tell you mine).

Honestly though, and perhaps you and I could discuss this in more depth, but I really think the Fall's '90s albums are better than their '00s albums. Their best '00s album, in my opinion, was Fall Heads Roll (this is of course, debatable) - but their body of work in the '90s was so different and varied that I don't think I could ever think their '00s work was better as a whole. Real New Fall LP and Imperial Wax Solvent and Fall Heads Roll? Great albums. But up against the likes of Code Selfish, Middle Class Revolt, Infotainment Scan, Levitate and The Marhsall Suite? I'll take their '90s output every time.

SGR 07-20-2020 07:29 AM

Oh really? For sure I'd be interested to read that! Do you have a link?

Sorry to hear about the depression - hopefully MusicBanter generally helps alleviate that instead of add to it. Do you have any plans on finishing the journal?

OccultHawk 01-08-2021 07:28 PM

https://www.google.com/amp/s/pitchfo...e-capitol/amp/

The Fall Announce New Live Album: Listen to “Leave the Capitol”

prophylacticpanic 01-14-2021 09:27 AM

Since you guys were telling me about these guys, I decided to check out Live at the Witch Trials. I know it's not necessarily the best decision in every occasion to start with a band's debut, but I couldn't resist with a title as great as that from such an appealing year (1979). And besides, getting a basis on what sound a band was founded on is always a good way of understanding their later efforts, if one chooses to venture them out as well.

Overall the music was quite good--compelling bass lines and drums working together nicely, good angular guitar, et cetera et cetera. "Frightened," "Music Scene," "Rebellious Jukebox," "Mother-Sister," "Futures and Pasts," "Two Steps Back," and the title monologue were my favorite tracks. Nice sound.

My biggest complaint, however is pretty unavoidable: Mark's voice. I know I'm going to sound like a prick for this, but British accents can be pretty grating to my ears for whatever reason, hence why Mark's vocals somewhat turned me off here. But that's just me. -_-

OccultHawk 01-14-2021 09:35 AM

When it comes to The Fall it is not for us to question. It is for us to bow before the glory.

Marie Monday 01-14-2021 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by prophylacticpanic (Post 2156056)
Since you guys were telling me about these guys, I decided to check out Live at the Witch Trials. I know it's not necessarily the best decision in every occasion to start with a band's debut, but I couldn't resist with a title as great as that from such an appealing year (1979). And besides, getting a basis on what sound a band was founded on is always a good way of understanding their later efforts, if one chooses to venture them out as well.

Overall the music was quite good--compelling bass lines and drums working together nicely, good angular guitar, et cetera et cetera. "Frightened," "Music Scene," "Rebellious Jukebox," "Mother-Sister," "Futures and Pasts," "Two Steps Back," and the title monologue were my favorite tracks. Nice sound.

My biggest complaint, however is pretty unavoidable: Mark's voice. I know I'm going to sound like a prick for this, but British accents can be pretty grating to my ears for whatever reason, hence why Mark's vocals somewhat turned me off here. But that's just me. -_-

His vocals are one of the main attractions to me, and to many other fall fans too I'm pretty sure, so if it's not your thing I guess it isn't easy for you to get into the Fall. Oh well. If you liked them well enough to look further then that's worth it though; their sound varied quite a lot over the years. Definitely not a hear-one-album-and-you've-heard-it-all-band

jadis 06-18-2021 05:51 PM

To me Live At The Witch Trials sounds like one of those debuts where a great band is almost there but not quite. The competent (yawn) drumming doesn't have that tribal, manic quality you get with The Fall at their best, the rough edges feel smoothed out, the atmosphere is not quite there.

This, on the other hand, is where it's at. A paranoid horror story sprinkled with gnomic utterances about "old golden savages" who "killed their philosophers", set to some deliciously primitive percussion, everything dripping with darkness.


jadis 06-18-2021 06:25 PM

Part of the problem for me is something about the way the drum sound is mixed in the Trials.

But I also suspect that he took several beatings from MES in order to make him less of a rock drummer (a very good one) and more of a Fall drummer. He does sound different on Hex. Maybe just part of the band refining their identity.

rostasi 06-18-2021 06:27 PM

Burns is monstrously great on that album - and just about everything else he did.

jadis 06-18-2021 07:10 PM

I haven't listened to Trials in a very long while, true. My issue was never with the quality of the drumming but with the overall feel - it's likely that I overstated the extent to which the drum sound contributes to it.

One day I'll have another go at overcoming the boredom this album brings about in me. Not today though. Today I'm perfectly content to be wrong about it.

jadis 06-18-2021 07:21 PM

The track that got me into the Fall is Burns at his brilliant best.



SGR 06-18-2021 08:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jadis (Post 2176770)
He does sound different on Hex. Maybe just part of the band refining their identity.

He might sound different because Hex featured a two-drummer lineup - Burns and Hanley. That said, I would agree that The Fall hadn't entirely come into their own on their first album. Regardless, their first album is downright excellent. Dragnet is better. And so is Grotesque. Of their massive discography, there are maybe two Fall records I don't legitimately enjoy listening to.

Marie Monday 06-19-2021 04:44 AM

I dunno, I like Witch Trails but I much prefer the few next ones. I love the drumming though, it's prominent but that's a good thing to me. But that's partly just my personal preference, I'm very partial to percussion.

Drjohnrock 06-19-2021 10:11 AM

Witch Trials also featured, IMO, the best Fall keyboard player, Yvonne Pawlett. Her playing was integral to the sound, not an afterthought. Witch Trials was a fine debut but the band really started coming into its own on Dragnet.

rostasi 06-19-2021 10:43 AM

Yeah, I had heard some singles on the radio when they came out:
Bingo Master’s... Totally Wired and ...’Elastic Man’, and loved them,
but the band didn’t really hit me until later in 1980 when the distributor
I was working for picked up Rough Trade. Both Grotesque... and Slates
came thru the door and were plopped down in front of me to sell and,
holy crap, I was immediately hooked!

The next year, they came to our city and the engineer at our radio station
named Tim Powell recorded them and two tracks were later released
on A Part of America, Therein (N.W.R.A. & Hip Priest).

Since that first gig, I’d seen them at least a dozen times.

SGR 06-19-2021 07:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rostasi (Post 2176834)
Since that first gig, I’d seen them at least a dozen times.

You're lucky as hell dude. What shows were the best/worst?

rostasi 06-19-2021 08:18 PM

The early years were always the best ones, I think, but even tho MES got more belligerent as he got older, there was always some kind of spectacle that would be happening when they played. In the early days of the 80s, there was the solid playing with an edge that was great and, then, in the mid 80s, I managed a record store and one of the guys who worked there went to high school with Brix and so on the night The Fall were to play, she came around to the store to hang out ... and then the concert itself, that night, was almost joyous in it’s energy. MES seemed like a happy guy and not the sloppy drunk he sometimes became at later shows (mostly, slurring lyrics to the point you had no idea what he was saying to constantly fucking with other members and their instruments while they were playing, etc...). The only time that had stopped happening during the later years was when he came out and did a whole show in a wheelchair ‘cause he had gone out a few days earlier for some cigs and fell on the ice. My wife started having doubts about going towards the end (and she’s a big fan) because she couldn’t understand what he was singing about on the tunes he wrote and was kinda uninspiring when he’d sing something he didn’t write, like Mr. Pharmacist.

SGR 06-20-2021 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rostasi (Post 2176951)
The early years were always the best ones, I think, but even tho MES got more belligerent as he got older, there was always some kind of spectacle that would be happening when they played. In the early days of the 80s, there was the solid playing with an edge that was great and, then, in the mid 80s, I managed a record store and one of the guys who worked there went to high school with Brix and so on the night The Fall were to play, she came around to the store to hang out ... and then the concert itself, that night, was almost joyous in it’s energy. MES seemed like a happy guy and not the sloppy drunk he sometimes became at later shows (mostly, slurring lyrics to the point you had no idea what he was saying to constantly fucking with other members and their instruments while they were playing, etc...). The only time that had stopped happening during the later years was when he came out and did a whole show in a wheelchair ‘cause he had gone out a few days earlier for some cigs and fell on the ice. My wife started having doubts about going towards the end (and she’s a big fan) because she couldn’t understand what he was singing about on the tunes he wrote and was kinda uninspiring when he’d sing something he didn’t write, like Mr. Pharmacist.

Well color me extremely jealous. I wish I had the chance to smoke some cigarettes with Brix and chat about her contributions to the Fall. As for MES, yeah, he was struggling at the end, but the fact that he still came out and performed in a wheel chair, despite his condition, instilled even more respect for him than I already had.

@elph - you finishing your Fall journal any time soon? Come on man, you got one album left.

rostasi 02-18-2022 09:10 PM

Brix Smith to release solo album ‘Valley Of The Dolls’, forms all-female live supergroup.

Queen Boo 02-21-2022 07:31 AM

Once had a dream where Mark E. Smith came to my house and made me do chores, it was weird.

rostasi 02-21-2022 10:10 AM

Was his name “Pete”? (sincere question)

SGR 02-24-2022 10:21 AM

From the link rostasi posted, looks like her 'supergroup' is gonna have two members of My Bloody Valentine.

And this quote:

“I’ve always been a woman in a man’s world,” she added. “The Fall were dirty, ugly blokes, you know?"

https://thumbs.gfycat.com/LividCalmC...restricted.gif

:laughing:

Queen Boo 02-24-2022 11:46 PM

Before I knew about The Fall back when he was Urban Hatemonger's avatar I thought he was just some random crazy old guy.

SGR 02-25-2022 07:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Queen Boo (Post 2200311)
Before I knew about The Fall back when he was Urban Hatemonger's avatar I thought he was just some random crazy old guy.

If MES was alive today, I don't think he'd take issue with that characterization.

Brix and Marcia were definitely an improvement to the band's image, from a 'maybe we can try and have a hit and a popular music video' point of view:

https://blackcountryrock.files.wordp...2783.jpg?w=800

Queen Boo 02-25-2022 12:47 PM

Mark really wasn't that bad looking in his youth, amphetamine is a hell of a drug.

SGR 02-25-2022 01:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2200364)
I think it was mostly the drinking, dude looked 40 at 25, dehydrated skin

It was honestly probably drinking + hard drugs + chain smoking altogether they aged him so quickly


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:35 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.