Everybody makes mistakes, R.E.M. makes mistakes, Motley Crue are a mistake.

And easy to say that Automatic For The People pwns anything Crue ever did.

Automatic For The People is my least favourite REM album up till that point.

I love both, but at the moment I'd listen to more Led Zeppelin. I just love Robert so much!

thats cause in the 70;s Robert Plant, and Jimmy Page were the sexiest men ever... :love: yum

I guess if you're into beastial, groupie raping satanists.

& pedophiliac.

I Dig

well if there in there early 20's and me being 18-19 years old i don't see that being wrong.. and theres nothing wrong with a little fling...just don't make yourself a slut out of it..

...'Cause im sure plant and page only dated 18-19 year olds, and it was just a fling then..

Are you a dumbass?
If your 18-19 there is nothing pedophillic about it. Do you know what pedophillic means?

i'm saying what it would be like for me.. I have a few dvd's about Jimmy Page and only him in the band being in his early 20's going out with a girl that was 13-14 model.. anyways but i'm of age.. and it wouldn't be rape.. and it wouldn't make me a slut.

Where did I say you were, and where did I say it was? I was attacking them not you.

I wasn't saying that you said those things, but i was making it clear about what i thought.

So you're saying you see nothing wrong with beastial, pedophillic, satanists?

Nothing wrong with pedophilic satanists.

See, it's the satanists that aren't animal-fucking pedophiles that you have to watch out for. They're seriously messed up.

Oh, and it was the 70's. Give them a break. They didn't have the internet to keep 'em busy. Sometimes the only thing you can do is **** a preteen and worship Satan.

I have been saying that for years http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f3...p/badteeth.gif

when you talk about things without saying "in my opinion" it's because it is a general truth.. and saying both bands are overrated is kinda harsh.. so add "in my opinion" and everyone will be happy :)
that was the manners lesson

For me it's a "no contest" situation. The only Beatles song I kinda like is Hey Jude, even if it seems a bit repetitive for me. Led zeppelin are far superior in my opinion.

i rly dont like either, but i think the beatles should win. because they gave the influence for all other rock bands, and probably inspired zepplin to start as well

If Led Zeppelin are pedophiles because of the cover for Houses Of The Holy then Nirvana are pedophiles for the cover of Nevermind, oddly enough, Cobain even said anyone who found the cover offesnive is a closet pedophile.

So if you think the Houses Of The Holy cover is offensive, you're a pedophile. ;)

Most modern rock album covers are pretty grotesque and perverted... Especially in the case of metal, punk and even some emo and indie... It all makes the Houses The Holy and Nevermind covers seem pretty tame by comparison.

No, they are pedophiles because they had sex with young children, nothing to do with album covers.

Care prove any of that?... Because i have a got feeling you're full of shit.

Closest thing to pedophilia in Zeps case is Page's relationship with a minor, who was like 15 or something... Which is nothing worse than what Jerry Lee Lewis has done.

Yeah, that is called pedophillia.
So we shouldn't arrest serial killers who have killed 9 people, because there are people who have killed 12?
That's your logic.

Calling a band crap because of their personal lives is the difinition of dumb logic.

John married a total bitch, so The Beatles suck ass.

I didn't call them crap.

Calling Zep and Nirvana crap makes up at least half of your entire post count.

Okay, calling Modest Mouse crap, or defending Nirvana makes up more than half of yours.

I have called MM crap at least 3 or 4 times on MB.

I'm not going to argue about this, but you had an entire argument with Ex D about it.

It wasn't that big, i said something about MM, she asked why i hate them so much, i gave my reasons, she made some response i don't even remember and that was it.

how did this one get bumped?(or am i just seeing things:confused:)
Anyways, w/o reading the last 11 pages, both are awesome imo!
Hard to decide which one I've listened to more...(i didn't have last.fm installed at that time)

It's a very strange question, given that the bands have virtually nothing in common at all other than being English.

I guess because they're both seen as massively influential, and are two of the most popular bands ever.

The Who.

Another dumb vs. thread....great!

Yes but it's a dumb thread started by the guy who started the site so have some respect damn you.

It is from back in 03 though. And regardless of who it was created by, it still doesn't change that.

It has nostalgic/sentimental/associative value and that is more significant, even I agree with that.

I don't like either, but The Beatles are the lesser of two evils.