Paedantic Basterd

It should be an academic debate, because people should be properly informed about the topics they're discussing, especially on matters of current events or policy.

Paul Smeenus

Think Again: Human Trafficking - By David A. Feingold | Foreign Policy

Paedantic Basterd

Oh good, it obscures the page with a subscription box I can't exit.

dhine31

These are good journals too

Rethinking Democracy: Legal Challenges to Pornography and Sex Inequality in Canada and the United States
Max Waltman
Political Research Quarterly , Vol. 63, No. 1 (Mar., 2010), pp. 218-237

Trafficking for Sexual Exploitation
Martti Lehti and Kauko Aromaa
Crime and Justice , Vol. 34, No. 1 (2006), pp. 133-227

Paul Smeenus

THINK AGAIN PRINT | TEXT SIZE | EMAIL | REPRINTS | SINGLE PAGE
Think Again: Human Trafficking
Judging by news headlines, human trafficking is a recent phenomenon. In fact, the coerced movement of people across borders is as old as the laws of supply and demand. What is new is the volume of the traffic -- and the realization that we have done little to stem the tide. We must look beyond our raw emotions if we are ever to stop those who trade in human lives.

BY DAVID A. FEINGOLD | AUGUST 30, 2005
"Most Victims Are Trafficked into the Sex Industry"
No. Trafficking of women and children (and, more rarely, young men) for prostitution is a vile and heinous violation of human rights, but labor trafficking is probably more widespread. Evidence can be found in field studies of trafficking victims across the world and in the simple fact that the worldwide market for labor is far greater than that for sex. Statistics on the "end use" of trafficked people are often unreliable because they tend to overrepresent the sex trade. For example, men are excluded from the trafficking statistics gathered in Thailand because, according to its national law, men cannot qualify as trafficking victims. However, a detailed 2005 study by the International Labour Organization (ILO) found that, of the estimated 9.5 million victims of forced labor in Asia, less than 10 percent are trafficked for commercial sexual exploitation. Worldwide, less than half of all trafficking victims are part of the sex trade, according to the same report.

Labor trafficking, however, is hardly benign. A study of Burmese domestic workers in Thailand by Mahidol University's Institute for Population and Social Research found beatings, sexual assault, forced labor without pay, sleep deprivation, and rape to be common. Another study by the German Agency for Technical Cooperation (GTZ) looked at East African girls trafficked to the Middle East and found that most were bound for oppressive domestic work, and often raped and beaten along the way. Boys from Cambodia and Burma are also frequently trafficked onto deep-sea commercial fishing boats, some of which stay at sea for up to two years. Preliminary research suggests 10 percent of these young crews never return, and boys that become ill are frequently thrown overboard.

The focus on the sex industry may galvanize action through moral outrage, but it can also cloud reason. A recent example is the unsubstantiated press reports that tsunami orphans in Indonesia's Aceh province were being abducted by organized gangs of traffickers. How such gangs could operate in an area bereft of roads and airstrips remains unclear, but that did not stop some U.S. organizations from appealing for funds to send "trained investigators" to track down the criminals. Although the devastation wrought by the tsunami certainly rendered people vulnerable -- mostly through economic disruption -- investigations by the United Nations have yet to identify a single confirmed case of sex trafficking.

dhine31

Sorry this wasn't the journal I was thinking of x

Paedantic Basterd

Paul Smeenus

But it's the same author you were thinking of, yet he's debunking your entire position.

seb860

That article only shows that sex trafficking isn't the biggest part of human trafficking. It tells us that slave labour is a big problem and comparably sex slavery affects less people.

It doesn't debunk his whole argument, just doesn't support it.

Scarlett O'Hara

This! It doesn't happen often enough around here.

__________________