Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Media (https://www.musicbanter.com/media/)
-   -   Official LOST Thread (https://www.musicbanter.com/media/39739-official-lost-thread.html)

someonecompletelyrandom 03-31-2010 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo (Post 844038)
-Room 23, what the hell is that all about?

Pretty much answered that question.

Rickenbacker 03-31-2010 04:59 PM

Yeah. That woman who works for Widmore told Said that the Dharma folks were doing experiments with subliminal messaging.

someonecompletelyrandom 03-31-2010 05:54 PM

Which was pretty obvious from the outset anyway. Alot of the stuff with the Dharma Init folks doesn't really need to be answered flat out, we can pretty much summize all the unimportant stuff.

OceanAndSilence 04-01-2010 12:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuna (Post 844080)
Can I travel back in time?

I'm literally kicking myself in the head over not watching this show earlier. I heard it hyped to no end, just like everybody else yet I never bothered to watch it until my dad got the first season out of the library. This show is awesome! I'm just bummed I discovered it so late and that this is the final season :(

eh, you've actually got it good; you don't have to wait a week between each episode.

Chubbosaurus 04-01-2010 01:01 AM

Yeah, I didn't follow the first few seasons when they were on tv. So I got to watch them with no week long interruptions! I watched all of season 5 in a day when I had swine flu, lol.

The fact that Jin and Sun STILL haven't been reunited is pissing me off! Oh man, it's so ridiculous. only 7 more episodes left! ... or 6. I'm not quite sure tbh :P

annapurna 04-01-2010 10:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo (Post 844038)
I was surprised to see that weird ass Room 23 to make another appearance. I always wondered what the hell that was all about.

Oh and Desmond is back, YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY.

Anyway, 6 eps left until the season finale, as great as this season has been, I'm pretty much convinced that all of the question won't be answered.

Here's a few of the things that have always bugged me and have yet to be answered.

-What was the deal with Walt? Why did the others want him? There's seriously a million questions about this kid that has never been answered.
Malcolm David Kelley might be back, Darlton will not confirm nor deny. They will get into his story though, definitely by Eendgame
-Why can't women have babies on the island? What were the others planning to do with Claire after taking her? Women couldn't have babies on the island because of the radioactive fallout caused by incident
-What's the cause of Hurley's curse? Is it really the numbers, what is their significance to the island?
it's the numbers, his awareness of them from being in DI and then using them to play lotto (even htough the trip to 1977 was in his future
-Libby... just, Libby. What's her backstory? Why was she a mental patient? Goddammit I want answers.
Libby will be back
-Why did the black smoke guy kill Mr. Eko, the flight 815 pilot and the members of Rousseau's science team?
-What is the sickness? Do Sayid and Claire really have it?
-What does Widmore really want with the island? Why is he no longer one of the others?
-Why did he want Ben?
-Why did Widmore need a medium, a physicist and an anthropologist on the island?
Because the island is a spiritual and scientific anomaly...in my opinion
-How did Ben become such a high ranking member of the others?
Because the Other's thought he could communicate with Jacob and because he ousted Widmore
-How did Ethan become one of the others and why did he betray his parents?
-How did that old lady know so much about Desmond and that he would end up on the island? I'm assuming Ms. Hawking has seen it possibly in a parallel universe
-WTF is up with the cabin?
-Is Jack's father really still alive? Is he on Flocke's side?
-Those old corpses in that cave, the ones Locke called "Adam and Eve", who are they?
-You remember that episode where the Swan station shut down with Locke trapped inside and some hellicopter or something dropped a huge crate of supplies? What the f*ck was that all about?
Darlton confirmed that that would be explained
-Remember the "whispers"? Yeah, what was that?
-Room 23, what the hell is that all about?
they said submilinal messaging, unless you don't buy it.
-What is the "magic box" Ben spoke of? How did it bring Locke's dad to the island?
-What's the deal with that Kevin Inman guy who was running the swan when Desmond showed up?
-Why did the others force Kate and Sawyer to build a runway? Did they know that eventually a plane would land on Hydra island?
-What's the deal with Dharma? How much do they know about the island? What's the origins of their feud with the others?

A ton a question will not get answered for sure, but I'm ok with that.
Do you think we're dealing with parallel universes?

Chubbosaurus 04-01-2010 11:26 AM

Thats what it seems, but it's as if the "flashed sideways". They were flashing forward and backwards like no tomorrow, then once the "incident" happened it just threw them into a flash sideways, so pretty much, a parallel universe I guess?

midnight rain 04-01-2010 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OceanAndSilence (Post 844214)
eh, you've actually got it good; you don't have to wait a week between each episode.

Then it loses its suspense and buildup though. That's what makes me truly love a tv show.

annapurna 04-01-2010 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chubbosaurus (Post 844365)
Thats what it seems, but it's as if the "flashed sideways". They were flashing forward and backwards like no tomorrow, then once the "incident" happened it just threw them into a flash sideways, so pretty much, a parallel universe I guess?

I'm assuming so. Throw in Minkowski spacetime and the Casimir Effect and I think the sideways reality makes sense. Desmond can travel to each dimension with full memories of his other "existence" and that may be what makes him special.

Chubbosaurus 04-01-2010 01:34 PM

Yeah! Omg that's so brilliant. I do really want to know why he is this so called "package", eeep I want tuesday to come so bad! I'm so sad that Lost is almost over :'(

Nine Black Poppies 04-02-2010 12:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 844050)
Pretty much answered that question.

Well, to a point. But what was the point of those experiments/what messages were being implanted?

I seem to recall one of the flashes in the video in that room has something to do with Jacob too (looked it up: "God Loves You As He Loved Jacob")--which makes me wonder... has there been any connection established that the Dharma knew anything about Jacob?

boo boo 04-02-2010 11:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rickenbacker (Post 844048)
I'm pretty sure we can infer that they are the corpses of Rose and Bernard.

How? I remember Hurley implying that they could be two of the plane crash survivors who died in the past after time traveling but this has yet to be proven.

Quote:

That was Farraday's mom. She knows everything basically.
Jack's explanation of future events was still a little vague, how did she know for example that Desmond choosing not to marry Penny at a certain point of time would lead to him crashing on the island?

boo boo 04-02-2010 11:33 AM

Quote:

Malcolm David Kelley might be back, Darlton will not confirm nor deny. They will get into his story though, definitely by Eendgame
Where did you get this info from? LostPedia?

Quote:

Women couldn't have babies on the island because of the radioactive fallout caused by incident
I guess that's good pseudo scientific explanation, I'll take it.

Quote:

it's the numbers, his awareness of them from being in DI and then using them to play lotto (even htough the trip to 1977 was in his future
I know Hurley believes it to be the numbers, but HOW? Why are they cursed in the first place?

Quote:

Libby will be back
She better be, otherwise she was a real red herring because there was all this build up to her being this mysterous character with a secret significance to what's going on, such as her being a patient at the same mental institution as Hurley and being the person who gave Desmond the sailboat he used in the race that eventually lead to him ending up on the island.

But she was killed off before we ever learned her story. And that pissed me off.

Quote:

Because the island is a spiritual and scientific anomaly...in my opinion
That's rather obvious. But what were Daniel, Miles and Charlotte's specific purposes on the island? They never bothered explaining this to anyone. Not even Naomi was told why these people she had to protect were so important to the mission.

Quote:

Because the Other's thought he could communicate with Jacob and because he ousted Widmore
I guess so, but why would Jacob allow for this? Wouldn't Richard have caught onto this since he actually DOES know Jacob?

Quote:

I'm assuming Ms. Hawking has seen it possibly in a parallel universe
WTF. Ok but how?

Quote:

Darlton confirmed that that would be explained
Good.

Quote:

they said submilinal messaging, unless you don't buy it.
I understood that much, but why is Dharma using such a thing? And why were the others using it on Karl that one time?

Chubbosaurus 04-02-2010 11:41 AM

Oh man, I totally forgot about it's use on Karl! I wanna know what it has to do with any of their studies and what not.

Rickenbacker 04-02-2010 11:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo (Post 844863)
How? I remember Hurley implying that they could be two of the plane crash survivors who died in the past after time traveling but this has yet to be proven.

Remember that recent episode when Rose and Bernard essentially removed themselves from the show and started living on their own? It's got to be them.

boo boo 04-02-2010 12:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rickenbacker (Post 844885)
Remember that recent episode when Rose and Bernard essentially removed themselves from the show and started living on their own? It's got to be them.

It could be.

But when they were last seen, that was in the late 70s. If you recall from way back in the first season, Jack said the corpses must be at least around 50 or 60 years old because of the deterioration of the clothing, and the late 70s would have been less than 30 years prior to when the corpses were found.

That could have just been a factual inconsistency on the writers' part but I don't think it is.

Remember, the incident sent all the time travelers back to the present, I think that would include Rose and Bernard.

Even if they weren't sent to the present and were killed by the explosion that creates the alternate timeline, they would have been completely obliterated, as in no corpses left behind, remember, in the alternate timeline the island is completely underwater. And besides, these corpses were found in the main timeline so I don't think that's what it is. It's pretty obvious that in the main timeline the island hasn't been destroyed.

noise 04-02-2010 12:55 PM

i have a theory.

everyone in the alternate timeline will die. starting with Sun.

otherwise, when our beloved characters escape from the island, there will be two of everybody running around...

Chubbosaurus 04-02-2010 12:58 PM

But in the alternate timeline, the Island doesn't exist. As shown in the first episode "LAX" the foot from the statue was under the ocean, thus the island not existing. So how could non exixtant people show up in a world of existant people from an alternate reality?

But I do see your theory, I guess the KWON on the cave wall is only for Jin.. (?)

someonecompletelyrandom 04-02-2010 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nine Black Poppies (Post 844751)
Well, to a point. But what was the point of those experiments/what messages were being implanted?

I seem to recall one of the flashes in the video in that room has something to do with Jacob too (looked it up: "God Loves You As He Loved Jacob")--which makes me wonder... has there been any connection established that the Dharma knew anything about Jacob?

I would guess it's just to see if brainwashing works. Maybe that slide was in there because they captured Hostiles and forced them to watch the film?

annapurna 04-02-2010 07:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo (Post 844873)
Where did you get this info from? LostPedia?

LOST Podcast. LOSTpedia is great too.


Quote:

I know Hurley believes it to be the numbers, but HOW? Why are they cursed in the first place?
Because he used the numbers from the island to play lotto, even if he didn't know that he obtained the number from the island. The numbers = The Valenzetti equation.


Quote:

She better be, otherwise she was a real red herring because there was all this build up to her being this mysterous character with a secret significance to what's going on, such as her being a patient at the same mental institution as Hurley and being the person who gave Desmond the sailboat he used in the race that eventually lead to him ending up on the island.

But she was killed off before we ever learned her story. And that pissed me off.
I think they let Cynthia Watros go because of the drunk driving incident (She got caught a few minutes after Michelle Rodriguez). Even though it's confirmed that she will be back, but doubt that will really explain her character.


Quote:

That's rather obvious. But what were Daniel, Miles and Charlotte's specific purposes on the island? They never bothered explaining this to anyone. Not even Naomi was told why these people she had to protect were so important to the mission.
I think they were sent to the island because all three of them had a previous connection to the island. All three was also candidates (scratched out) according to MiBs cave and the Lighthouse dial. IMO, the whole science team was a ruse to get them there. If there was a specific scientific mission, they haven't mentioned it yet. Daniel was there to initiate "The Incident" and Miles helped convince his father to evacuate the Island.

Quote:

I guess so, but why would Jacob allow for this? Wouldn't Richard have caught onto this since he actually DOES know Jacob?
Jacob is hands-off (ha!) on the island. He wanted Ben to make the right decision on his own.


Quote:

WTF. Ok but how?
You think we're supposed to know that yet? ;)

Quote:

I understood that much, but why is Dharma using such a thing? And why were the others using it on Karl that one time?
To brainwash people. When the Others took over the DI, it's highly likely that they added the "Jacob" messages. I'm also pretty sure that Ben put Karl in Room 23 because he was pissed. Don't know why Walt was in there. Maybe they'll explain that one later...maybe.

annapurna 04-07-2010 04:09 PM

No thoughts on last night? Desmond episodes are AMAZING.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-07-2010 04:11 PM

For the first time ever I missed it. I'm going to watch it tonight.

Rickenbacker 04-07-2010 04:16 PM

It was a really excellent episode. Loved every minute of it.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-07-2010 04:17 PM

I've got to ignore this thread until I see it. Could be a week from now :(

Rickenbacker 04-07-2010 04:18 PM

But it's on Hulu as we speak!

Akira 04-07-2010 04:29 PM

Best episode of the season so far, as Desmond's episodes usually are. Though not hard considering the junk they've shown so far. Only really liked one other episode this season, the rest have been the usual filler and time wasting.

boo boo 04-07-2010 11:18 PM

Really? Every episode this season reveals something crucial to the plot, how is that filler?

I think this season has been very good and the build up is driving me nuts.

duga 04-07-2010 11:22 PM

Yeah, I wouldn't say filler, but I definitely think it was going too slow for my tastes. This last episode was killer, but the one before I found to be another slow going one. The one right before that was killer as well, though...so I have a good feeling about the next ones.

OceanAndSilence 04-08-2010 12:49 AM

I always love desmond's episodes... so I'll see...

Janszoon 04-08-2010 06:55 AM

How about them finally tying in the alternate-time line! I was pretty excited about that. Great episode overall.

Akira 04-08-2010 10:51 AM

It's filler in the fact that a scene at the temple which would take ten minutes for any of us to get through took several episodes, with not much explanation. The fact that there are a few episodes left and so many things to wrap up and yet we're wasting time watching Sun get hit over the head and only being able to speak Korean. A lot of it feels like season 3 rather than the concluding episodes of a great tv show. They could eliminate the 'time wasting' scenes and make the really good bits better and longer. The good parts of this season have been awesome.

noise 04-08-2010 11:56 PM

most of the last episode was very good, but i think it contained the biggest WTF moment in the entire show.

desmond and faraday are sitting on a bench chatting. faraday pulls out a notebook filled with equations he wrote, then launches into a tirade about setting off a nuclear weapon to stop something really really bad from happening and thereby changing the course of time.

where the hell did he pull all that from?

Nine Black Poppies 04-09-2010 12:13 AM

I got the impression that seeing Charlotte made him remember all of that from the main timeline, much in the same way Desmond remembered things about Penny when confronted with the parallel situation with Charlie in the water. They remember because something in them knows that what they're experiencing in the alternate timeline wasn't supposed to happen, something just has to bring out the part of them that senses that. Which apparently is what Desmond now intends to do to everybody else.

Chubbosaurus 04-13-2010 03:11 PM

I'm pretty excited about tonight's episode. Gin and Sun better be reunited, Desmond has to figure out ****, and I wanna see Charlie again. Then I will be truly happy. I also really really really want Claire and Charlie back together.. Some way, some how. It's just how it has to be!

:D pumped

someonecompletelyrandom 04-13-2010 03:17 PM

I loved last week's episode. The preview for this week sucked, but it DID appear to be a Hurley episode. If that's the case, they better get to answering the only question I care about at this point... WHY was Libby in that dang hospital?? I don't care if they explain it away in one sentence like "Oh, it's because my Husband died" i'll just be happy to get an answer!

Chubbosaurus 04-13-2010 03:22 PM

Agreed! She would be such a pointless character if they don't touch up on her again. I also want to know what makes those specific numbers so "unlucky" and significant I guess you can say. I love Hurley, and most Hurley episodes are good ones.

duga 04-13-2010 10:55 PM

So. She just kinda blew up. That was fairly interesting.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-13-2010 10:56 PM

What an insanely good episode.

Quote:

Originally Posted by duga (Post 849998)
So. She just kinda blew up. That was fairly interesting.

NEVER expected her to go Doc Arntz.

boo boo 04-14-2010 05:38 PM

I'm glad this Libby thing finally got some revolve, though I'd still like to learn more about her, she says she admitted herself, and if that's so it's probably out of depression stemmed from the death of her husband as revealed in the first Desmond episode way back from the season 2 finale.

And I didn't expect Illana to go out the way she did at all, I swear Lost writers pull this sh*t all the time, build up all this mystery around a character, making you want to learn more about that person but then kaboom, gone.

For a woman handpicked by Jacob to protect the candidates she wasn't too bright, you don't just toss a bag of obviously unstable, 160 year old dynamite on the f*cking ground.

I also hope Desmond survives, being thrown down a well RIGHT after his longly anticipated return would be a pretty lame way for him to go out.

Nine Black Poppies 04-14-2010 06:58 PM

Yeah, Desmond's definitely not done yet. He, thus far, seems to be the only character that smokey Locke is at all afraid of--they're not gonna just throw him down a well and be done with him. (Plus, there's probably something significant down there he's going to encounter, based on what was said about the well.)

I'm not completely satisfied with the way they brought Libby back either, but at least they're acknowledging her again. And her presence in the alternate timeline may still be significant both there and in the main timeline. I think, though, in the alternate timeline, her checking into the hospital had something/more to do with her having the "delusional" memories of the main timeline, because when Hurley went to see her, she implied that those memories came to her before she got there.

What I'm curious about is what Desmond hoped to achieve by running down alternate Locke--what effect that's supposed to have.

And what role Locke (real/dead or otherwise) still has to play in this. Because according to the the lighthouse, Locke is one of the 6 numbers and it seems like all the numbers (4-Locke, 8-Hurley, 15-Sawyer, 16-Sayid, 23-Jack, 42-either Sun or Jin) all have to be together to leave the island or do whatever is supposed to happen.

Also, wtf happened to Eloise to make her so clairvoyant about everything (in both timelines)--to a degree that no one else seems to be? That's been bugging me for a while now...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:21 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.