No punk today - Music Banter Music Banter

Go Back   Music Banter > The Music Forums > Punk
Register Blogging Today's Posts
Welcome to Music Banter Forum! Make sure to register - it's free and very quick! You have to register before you can post and participate in our discussions with over 70,000 other registered members. After you create your free account, you will be able to customize many options, you will have the full access to over 1,100,000 posts.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 10-17-2013, 08:50 PM   #1 (permalink)
Lord Larehip
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by William_the_Bloody View Post
I think the obvious point being missed here is race. Both punk and heavy metal are subgenres that evolved from white youths. In the past, mosh pits could be hostile environments for someone with the wrong pigmentation.
I disagree. Unless you're referring to the skinheads but I saw them beating up whites far more than I saw them beating up anyone else. Punk is very anti-racist. Can't say about metal for certain but the majority of metalheads are not racially motivated. I have friends that are punks and friends that are metalheads and I would say they are more critical of each other than either faction is towards blacks. Metal is more ambivalent towards race but punk is outwardly anti-racist. The very first hardcore band was black.

Quote:
Rap evolved from black youths who felt shut out from white society, and the music continues to be the chosen vehicle of expression for non white immigrants in many western nations. Take the rise of Grime music in London.
There are huge numbers of white kids into rap and hip-hop.

Quote:
I love both genres, that being said, they both suck musically, and have done their fair share of damage to the decline of music in western society.

Punk rock is generally simplistic and easy to play rock music consisting of eighth and sixteenth note drives. When Green Day & the Offspring went mainstream it lowered the talent bar for what is acceptable for mainstream rock. They spawned a generation of **** bands, that can not hold a candle to the Pink Floyd, Fleetwood Mac, The Rolling Stones, the Eagles ect.
Green Day couldn't hold a candle to a real punk band. The other bands you mention also did their share of lowering the bar. None of them were exactly Mozart, Stravinsky, Miles or Bird. Every after-school band I played in in high school did "Train Kept A-Rollin'" a la Aerosmith (who ripped off the Yarbirds version) but none of us ever did it like Tiny Bradshaw and couldn't if we had wanted to. It was far too complex. It's incredible how much you have to know about your instrument to play jazz and (real) R&B. Until I took up double bass, I had no idea. The more you learn, the more you realize there is to know. It seems like there's no end in sight.

Quote:
Rap music is based on sampling beats, which severely restricts your artistic creativity. Sure there are creative geniuses out there like Dr. Dre, but for far too long the music been hijacked by talentless douchebags who rely on image and worn out gangster lingo to sell their records.
I wish rap would get back to the jazz and beat poetry but it is not going to happen.

Quote:
Would anyone care to argue that Lil Wayne can hold a candle to Curtis Mayfield?
Curtis Mayfield was a genius. For that matter, so was Percy Mayfield--give him a listen some time.
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-17-2013, 10:52 PM   #2 (permalink)
Music Addict
 
William_the_Bloody's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Sunnydale Cemetary
Posts: 2,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post
I disagree. Unless you're referring to the skinheads but I saw them beating up whites far more than I saw them beating up anyone else. Punk is very anti-racist. Can't say about metal for certain but the majority of metalheads are not racially motivated. I have friends that are punks and friends that are metalheads and I would say they are more critical of each other than either faction is towards blacks. Metal is more ambivalent towards race but punk is outwardly anti-racist. The very first hardcore band was black.
Your referring to one philosophy of punk, punk is not defined by one political ideology, there is left wing punk, there is right wing punk, there is unbiased and non political punk. The New York hardcore scene had very different social values than California punk scene.

I never said punk or metal was racist, but I implied that particularly during the 80's, bigotry in the punk & metal scene were commonplace amongst many fans, if not some of the bands themselves, it wasn't the paradise of diversity many people like to romanticize it as.

The fact remains that punk and metal were and still are primarily white subculture musical genres. Bad Brains was not the first hardcore band, the first official hardcore release is usually cited as D.O.A.'s hardcore 81. They toured the east coast and had an impact on bands like Minor Threat.

One black band amongst a sea of white bands does not make a diverse musical scene regardless of anti racist factions in punk.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post
There are huge numbers of white kids into rap and hip-hop.
Yes of course there is, rap in the late 80's was the new punk, but it was punk for those people who were not white, and continues to be the musical choice for many non white migrants. If...I believe you did at some point...state that rap sucks, you are essentially telling a whole generation of African Americans that there culture is garbage.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post

Green Day couldn't hold a candle to a real punk band. The other bands you mention also did their share of lowering the bar. None of them were exactly Mozart, Stravinsky, Miles or Bird. Every after-school band I played in in high school did "Train Kept A-Rollin'" a la Aerosmith (who ripped off the Yarbirds version) but none of us ever did it like Tiny Bradshaw and couldn't if we had wanted to. It was far too complex. It's incredible how much you have to know about your instrument to play jazz and (real) R&B. Until I took up double bass, I had no idea. The more you learn, the more you realize there is to know. It seems like there's no end in sight.
Fair enough but to my knowledge Tiny Bradshaw never had a number 1 hit record, you can correct me if I am wrong. As far as pop music goes, the talent gap between Buddy Holly and Pink Floyd is arguable. The talent gap between Pink Floyd and Green Day is largely noticeable.
William_the_Bloody is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-17-2013, 11:54 PM   #3 (permalink)
Lord Larehip
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by William_the_Bloody View Post
Your referring to one philosophy of punk, punk is not defined by one political ideology, there is left wing punk, there is right wing punk, there is unbiased and non political punk. The New York hardcore scene had very different social values than California punk scene.
I sampled different scenes all over the country because I was in the service at the time and I'd have to say punk is predominantly left wing if not extreme left wing. Then the apolitical punks would come next with right wing bringing up the rear--I never met any, personally.

Quote:
I never said punk or metal was racist, but I implied that particularly during the 80's, bigotry in the punk & metal scene were commonplace amongst many fans, if not some of the bands themselves, it wasn't the paradise of diversity many people like to romanticize it as.
Well, I was there in the 80s and I moshed from Michigan to Massachusetts to New York to Philly to Virginia to Chicago to Milwaukee to St. Louis to Cincinnati to Florida. I can't say I saw any real bigotry. I'm not sure what you mean.

Quote:
The fact remains that punk and metal were and still are primarily white subculture musical genres.
Once again, I've met a lot of black punks. And I've met a lot of black punk musicians. True, it's predominantly white but there are or at least were a significant number of black punks. Frankly, I saw them everywhere I went and corresponded with one who lived in California because I was contributing to a zine he was running. If we are to believe him, he took more flak from other blacks for being punk than he did from whites. Really, whites didn't care because blacks at the punk venues was not at all uncommon. I saw black guys and girls at punk clubs in every city I visited.

Quote:
Bad Brains was not the first hardcore band, the first official hardcore release is usually cited as D.O.A.'s hardcore 81. They toured the east coast and had an impact on bands like Minor Threat.
Again, I have a DVD called "American Hardcore." It has no narrator, it's just the hardcore bands and promoters and what not talking and they say Bad Brains was the first. Ian Mackaye, if I remember correctly, acknowledges Bad Brains as the first hardcore band. He talks about them quite a bit at any rate. You can take it up with these guys. There were there, they were the movers and shakers. I'll take their word for it.

Quote:
One black band amongst a sea of white bands does not make a diverse musical scene regardless of anti racist factions in punk.
There was more than one. I mention them specifically because they are said to be the first. Many of the bands had black and white members. The most famous one I can think of is the Dead Kennedys. Their drummer, Darren Henley, is black. He had fans independent of the DKs.

Quote:
Yes of course there is, rap in the late 80's was the new punk, but it was punk for those people who were not white
No, it was rap. There were plenty of black punks in the 80s--believe me.

Quote:
and continues to be the musical choice for many non white migrants. If...I believe you did at some point...state that rap sucks, you are essentially telling a whole generation of African Americans that there culture is garbage.
A lot of their culture IS garbage. The out-of-wedlock birthrate is downright ridiculous--upwards of 70% from I am given to understand. The crime rate in black communities still remains the highest in the nation. 500,000 people have left Detroit in an last few years because the crime rate is among the highest in the country. The small businesses have left because they are tired of getting robbed. And a lot of that has to do with the affects of rap on the minds of young black men.
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-18-2013, 12:51 AM   #4 (permalink)
Music Addict
 
William_the_Bloody's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Sunnydale Cemetary
Posts: 2,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post
I sampled different scenes all over the country because I was in the service at the time and I'd have to say punk is predominantly left wing if not extreme left wing. Then the apolitical punks would come next with right wing bringing up the rear--I never met any, personally.

Well, I was there in the 80s and I moshed from Michigan to Massachusetts to New York to Philly to Virginia to Chicago to Milwaukee to St. Louis to Cincinnati to Florida. I can't say I saw any real bigotry. I'm not sure what you mean.


Once again, I've met a lot of black punks. And I've met a lot of black punk musicians. True, it's predominantly white but there are or at least were a significant number of black punks. Frankly, I saw them everywhere I went and corresponded with one who lived in California because I was contributing to a zine he was running. If we are to believe him, he took more flak from other blacks for being punk than he did from whites. Really, whites didn't care because blacks at the punk venues was not at all uncommon. I saw black guys and girls at punk clubs in every city I visited.
Sure there were black punks, Ice T and company use to go punk clubs on the strip in the 80's. You may have not experienced racism in the scene, I did. The New York Hardcore scene for all its right wing values was very diverse, Puerto Rican skinheads, black skinheads, the riot in Southall London in 1981 is another side of the coin.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post

Again, I have a DVD called "American Hardcore." It has no narrator, it's just the hardcore bands and promoters and what not talking and they say Bad Brains was the first. Ian Mackaye, if I remember correctly, acknowledges Bad Brains as the first hardcore band. He talks about them quite a bit at any rate. You can take it up with these guys. There were there, they were the movers and shakers. I'll take their word for it.
I have seen the video, D.O.A. is largely considered the first punk band to cross into hardcore, and is known for coining the phrase with the album Hardcore 81.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post

There was more than one. I mention them specifically because they are said to be the first. Many of the bands had black and white members. The most famous one I can think of is the Dead Kennedys. Their drummer, Darren Henley, is black. He had fans independent of the DKs.


No, it was rap. There were plenty of black punks in the 80s--believe me.
Historically there is only one notable black hardcore band and that is Bad Brains, I could go through a list of 100 historic punk bands before I get to another notable punk band consisting of all African Americans. Yes there were black punks, but it wasn't rooted in their culture. Black kids in the south Bronx weren't running out in mass to load up on Agnostic Front records.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post
A lot of their culture IS garbage. The out-of-wedlock birthrate is downright ridiculous--upwards of 70% from I am given to understand. The crime rate in black communities still remains the highest in the nation. 500,000 people have left Detroit in an last few years because the crime rate is among the highest in the country. The small businesses have left because they are tired of getting robbed. And a lot of that has to do with the affects of rap on the minds of young black men.
You said it not me! For a supposed anti racist white punk rocker that argument sounds like something Patrick Buchanan would frame. If your going to take the left wing side on the culture war, than you have to take the responsibility of the family breakdown that has happened since the late 60's onward to both black and WHITE working class communities.

Out of wedlock birthrates and high crime rates isn't a result of Black culture! it is the result of being ghettoized & impoverished from years of racial discrimination. In short, being at the bottom of the food chain in a post culture war environment.
William_the_Bloody is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-18-2013, 11:11 AM   #5 (permalink)
Lord Larehip
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by William_the_Bloody View Post
Out of wedlock birthrates and high crime rates isn't a result of Black culture! it is the result of being ghettoized & impoverished from years of racial discrimination.
You say that as though there is no connection. There's a HUGE connection.

From this article:
Blacks struggle with 72 percent unwed mothers rate - Health - Women's health | NBC News

The black community's 72 percent rate eclipses that of most other groups: 17 percent of Asians, 29 percent of whites, 53 percent of Hispanics and 66 percent of Native Americans were born to unwed mothers in 2008, the most recent year for which government figures are available. The rate for the overall U.S. population was 41 percent.

Further:

Lucas says 42 percent of all black women and 70 percent of professional black women are unmarried.

That means black women of lesser economic status and lower education are actually more likely to be married. So while impoverishment IS a cause of illegitimate birth, it is clearly not the only dynamic at work in the black community.

I visited an online forum a few months ago populated mainly by black women. I didn't post, I just wanted to see what topics were being discussed. The very first thread I saw listed was titled: "Are black men marriageable?" It had thousands of responses and was already three years old and still getting responses every day. Can you imagine white women asking this question about white men? Clearly there is a problem in the black community and it is affecting blacks regardless of their economic status or education level. And if that doesn't have an enormous impact on black culture, what the hell does? If impoverishment and prison don't have an enormous impact on black culture, what the hell does? If a generation of blacks growing up with only one parent doesn't have an enormous impact on black culture, what they hell does? And if a music is telling young black men that to be a success, they need to act like Scarface (a very popular movie among young blacks), well, what do you think is going to happen?

Why Do Rappers Love Scarface?

To the question "Why do black people like Scarface so much?" Here was a black person's answer:

Probably the same reason why most white guys things like likes Jackass the movie. Different tastes for different cultures.

More specifically, because Scarface represents a non-white guy from basically the ghetto, who made it big with toughness, smarts, and force in a country where it's hard to go so far so fast if your not a well off white dude.


So, you see, blacks know it is culture. The only people who don't are bleeding-heart PC liberals who will blame everybody but blacks because they think that would make them a racist.

Quote:
In short, being at the bottom of the food chain in a post culture war environment.
Again, this excuses blacks for self-destructive trends in their communities which cannot be fixed by anyone BUT blacks themselves. And with this "It's not your fault" mentality, don't expect that to happen any time soon.
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-18-2013, 09:36 PM   #6 (permalink)
Music Addict
 
William_the_Bloody's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: Sunnydale Cemetary
Posts: 2,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post
You say that as though there is no connection. There's a HUGE connection.

From this article:
Blacks struggle with 72 percent unwed mothers rate - Health - Women's health | NBC News

The black community's 72 percent rate eclipses that of most other groups: 17 percent of Asians, 29 percent of whites, 53 percent of Hispanics and 66 percent of Native Americans were born to unwed mothers in 2008, the most recent year for which government figures are available. The rate for the overall U.S. population was 41 percent.

Further:

Lucas says 42 percent of all black women and 70 percent of professional black women are unmarried.

That means black women of lesser economic status and lower education are actually more likely to be married. So while impoverishment IS a cause of illegitimate birth, it is clearly not the only dynamic at work in the black community.

I visited an online forum a few months ago populated mainly by black women. I didn't post, I just wanted to see what topics were being discussed. The very first thread I saw listed was titled: "Are black men marriageable?" It had thousands of responses and was already three years old and still getting responses every day. Can you imagine white women asking this question about white men? Clearly there is a problem in the black community and it is affecting blacks regardless of their economic status or education level. And if that doesn't have an enormous impact on black culture, what the hell does? If impoverishment and prison don't have an enormous impact on black culture, what the hell does? If a generation of blacks growing up with only one parent doesn't have an enormous impact on black culture, what they hell does? And if a music is telling young black men that to be a success, they need to act like Scarface (a very popular movie among young blacks), well, what do you think is going to happen?

Why Do Rappers Love Scarface?

To the question "Why do black people like Scarface so much?" Here was a black person's answer:

Probably the same reason why most white guys things like likes Jackass the movie. Different tastes for different cultures.

More specifically, because Scarface represents a non-white guy from basically the ghetto, who made it big with toughness, smarts, and force in a country where it's hard to go so far so fast if your not a well off white dude.


So, you see, blacks know it is culture. The only people who don't are bleeding-heart PC liberals who will blame everybody but blacks because they think that would make them a racist.



Again, this excuses blacks for self-destructive trends in their communities which cannot be fixed by anyone BUT blacks themselves. And with this "It's not your fault" mentality, don't expect that to happen any time soon.
I never said there isn't a problem within the black community, I merley stated their problem is the worst because of generations of family breakdown, largely due to historic racism and discrimination, not because they happen to be black.

Black families were broken apart in the south and herded off like cattle for the slave trade. Northern black families were dispossessed and forced into ghetto enclaves.

We now live in a moral relative post Christian society, and they are bearing the blunt of the decline in family values, while being blindsided with the lucrative profits that can be made from prohibition.

For the record, this isn't a political stance, I'm neither left nor right, I'm just stating facts. I'm agnostic & politically ambivalent, I believe that evolution will run its course and therefore most political issues are pre determined either way.


Anyways you made your point. You think that rap sucks, that a lot of African American culture is garbage, and that a small minority of black punk rockers somehow represented of black youth on a whole.
William_the_Bloody is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-19-2013, 12:40 PM   #7 (permalink)
Zum Henker Defätist!!
 
The Batlord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Beating GNR at DDR and keying Axl's new car
Posts: 48,199
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by William_the_Bloody View Post
I never said there isn't a problem within the black community, I merley stated their problem is the worst because of generations of family breakdown, largely due to historic racism and discrimination, not because they happen to be black.

Black families were broken apart in the south and herded off like cattle for the slave trade. Northern black families were dispossessed and forced into ghetto enclaves.

We now live in a moral relative post Christian society, and they are bearing the blunt of the decline in family values, while being blindsided with the lucrative profits that can be made from prohibition.

For the record, this isn't a political stance, I'm neither left nor right, I'm just stating facts. I'm agnostic & politically ambivalent, I believe that evolution will run its course and therefore most political issues are pre determined either way.


Anyways you made your point. You think that rap sucks, that a lot of African American culture is garbage, and that a small minority of black punk rockers somehow represented of black youth on a whole.
Freudian slip is Freudian.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by J.R.R. Tolkien
There is only one bright spot and that is the growing habit of disgruntled men of dynamiting factories and power-stations; I hope that, encouraged now as ‘patriotism’, may remain a habit! But it won’t do any good, if it is not universal.
The Batlord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-19-2013, 09:45 AM   #8 (permalink)
Registered Jimmy Rustler
 
Dr_Rez's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: USA
Posts: 5,375
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post

Once again, I've met a lot of black punks. And I've met a lot of black punk musicians. True, it's predominantly white but there are or at least were a significant number of black punks. Frankly, I saw them everywhere I went and corresponded with one who lived in California because I was contributing to a zine he was running. If we are to believe him, he took more flak from other blacks for being punk than he did from whites. Really, whites didn't care because blacks at the punk venues was not at all uncommon. I saw black guys and girls at punk clubs in every city I visited.
.
Lol you can not seriously be arguing this. If you have been to a third the shows you say you have then you would realize the punk and especially metal crowd are VERY low in black population.

Hell last time I went to Ozzfest with my 2 black friends they were playing find a black guy game because they seemed like the only 2 out of 10000 people. No one is saying none exist but come on dude metal is predominantly white males.
__________________
*Best chance of losing virginity is in prison crew*
*Always Checks Credentials Crew*
*nba > nfl crew*
*Shave one of my legs to pretend its a girl in my bed crew*
Dr_Rez is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-19-2013, 11:06 AM   #9 (permalink)
Lord Larehip
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rezdaddy Longlegs View Post
Lol you can not seriously be arguing this. If you have been to a third the shows you say you have then you would realize the punk and especially metal crowd are VERY low in black population.

Hell last time I went to Ozzfest with my 2 black friends they were playing find a black guy game because they seemed like the only 2 out of 10000 people. No one is saying none exist but come on dude metal is predominantly white males.
I doubt you'd see many punks at an Ozzfest either.
  Reply With Quote
Old 10-19-2013, 12:41 PM   #10 (permalink)
Registered Jimmy Rustler
 
Dr_Rez's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: USA
Posts: 5,375
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Larehip View Post
I doubt you'd see many punks at an Ozzfest either.
Lol ok because a true punk fan has to look a certain way...You dont think the metal and punk crowd overlap in 2013??
???

?


?
???

I bet I know more about punk music than most of the dirty jeans wearing ripped tshirt anti government "punks" hanging out at the greasy "punk" club in whatever crappy town you are in. I am clean, have a job, dont entirely hate society, and think anarchy is a terrible idea. Guess I dont like punk.
__________________
*Best chance of losing virginity is in prison crew*
*Always Checks Credentials Crew*
*nba > nfl crew*
*Shave one of my legs to pretend its a girl in my bed crew*
Dr_Rez is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Similar Threads



© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.