Music Banter - The Official Green Day Thread

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)

- Punk (https://www.musicbanter.com/punk/)

- - The Official Green Day Thread (https://www.musicbanter.com/punk/10222-official-green-day-thread.html)

Quote:

Only album I may rank a bit higher in terms of albums that make me nostalgic for those years is Weezer - Blue.

Weezer's blue album is really good. So was makebelieve.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BastardofYoung (Post 1421606)

To me, "Insomniac" just felt like an album of songs that could have been recorded during the sessions, but were not used. Also had my favorite Green Day song of all-time.

It felt rushed, I think it was out within a year of "Dookie" being released, seems like it was just one of those albums that the studio told them to put out ASAP cause they had an unexpected hit with "Dookie" and thought they could capitalize on it by getting it out ASAP.

But I liked it a lot when it came out, it had a more dark side to it, still had some of the goofiness from "Dookie", but also had a more abrasive tone to it.

Up until "American Idiot", it was their second best selling album after "Dookie". Did not match the sales of that album, but was not a total waste either.

I like it just as much in its own way. I would go "Kerplunk!" > "Dookie" > "Insomniac" as my top 3 Green Day albums.

The bassline in the song Stuart and the Ave. is one of my all time favorites.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GreenDayPunk (Post 1424665)

The bassline in the song Stuart and the Ave. is one of my all time favorites.

It is a gooder. I like Mike Dirnt as a bassist.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Honestlift Official (Post 1422090)

Weezer's blue album is really good. So was makebelieve.

Yeah, to me Weezer took a nose dive when Matt Sharp parted ways. They had some moments, but overall Matt contributed so much to their formula. I remember first hearing the Green Album and I was not impressed.

Blue and Pinkerton just get me more in the mood. As did "Return of the Rentals", which I think is a super fun album.

I honestly like 21st century breakdown as much as American Idiot. Call me mad if you want but I can't get people who praise Idiot and put it's follow up down.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BastardofYoung (Post 1424684)

Thats exactly where they fell off. Matt was really the most integral part of that band and it showed in their follow ups. I can't imagine dealing with the ego of Rivers.

Dookie is Green Day's best album in my opinion. I'm a big fan of their pre-American Idiot sound though.

39/Smooth vs Kerplunk

I actually think 39/Smooth sounds better than Kerplunk in terms of production quality and overall sound. I especially think the guitar sounds better. However, Kerplunk's songs are more like Green Day's Dookie pop-punk sound.

Is it just me or do you guys think so too?

I cant believe the RHOF nominated them. There so overrated

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soulflower (Post 1497374)

I cant believe the RHOF nominated them. There so overrated

I haven't actually listened to them for years but I think they are a good 3 piece band. And you have to give them credit for longevity. They've been around since the early to mid nineties I believe.